ميزان
نقض حكم باستحقاق عامل خرج على المعاش ما يوازي 40 شهرًا لاشتراكه في صندوق التكافل الاجتماعي: الحكم اتخذ تقرير الخبير دعامة لقضائه دون تناول الدفاع الجوهري للطاعن بالبحث والتمحيص
lr r r ii,,. J.r,ogr.rJ t,c V ar'lrl.r
LJ,;4J,{lJl
"r+J,: +[i-):-- _.,.rLiJl ,uc. . ^- " /rt i,r...tl rla iau]
.itG .a.s-ll -J- _,,rJ[ 6]i +, ^ _l,6111^ ll ;all 1L^rz.4L_i:-Jl i.rLJt
.6Jl1rJl i,-* ,^- .,e -,.-s.'Jl
(Y\Y)
fulr, :a rl 11 ar.,J tvl t fJ a,rlaJl
.e.G$l iosro .r:+:-iJl .,3 $,.aiJlrl J9,,4! (6J-oJ+ etiJ,, etir . gU,cJ (l)
.uu,aJl d 6LJl +13:+g: <,1c.,.:rr. Jl r-- .5.rJ1 1jL+ll 3Ll-rJl 4-. r Jl -..1^rl
.elli JG;I a-A:!_! +r. qU. Y! es;sll r"S* rtjJt
.<a-dc,'.olaJJ AJJlll blJl,l :i.,-olrll ,icEoJlp {_4r ^:.; orlrrcLs (y)
J,-,ll ri itiJl 3l .E.l :: ll .r* LJi ?i- {:-r.- ,LFrl ills j 4ilc ,._jll gt : ^r . ..1
Xl .4tJ*i.r.i,- 'rl cll;;Yl .r,-l;'t,*;i"r;.;l J.rLr, e,uL iJ_L,rrru+U
.3Jl 6& JL^<:. J LrJr a;Ji,l{ irt ..:1,;.*.;-;re gr,t tl .,.! 4(Lj*i:t iJ_ ulnj
.e[] AL . \11\ iLJ \A fJ L**l -Eil.-- JG l.s. JJt. ^rl i-j)llL rJ.,c y .oji
csJ q ;+ 1G.r <-=.3 31 1,U 6 Ai - i-"<--ll 6t! .t .:: s-i - rJ-lfl - \
+ -i. rr,li -19-- L"i <;.f,^i: ;i 1';.+.tt &A t+:ll :.fU; L-;./t i_S-_.
Yb a.,-ti *+*C 1$ =,r_-;l A-S_ll ,r.Js _..rr cssc,Lll ,i,eirJl +-=3 r:+;
.o;33 i,,,i. :,l+-Xl .r. fug r, -<- ,0..1
1Ll +-cG; .,.i.:!*n ;i;reGJl &JiJl .,l .sJ,E Jl ,rj.-,LlJl ;L( jl _ y
J,--l rS aa.iJl + 9GJX i,J,-11 i_:.+ll 6'.,l.rl ,-\ -,..r,*.r..,! &;Jll LS=-
s-L-Xl ltbJl ,J*+-;;i_i \tly ii_J ytv fJ rlJFilt \11y/\\/y\ e,Jt r:.
Y. . ' ai- Jsrrr r. v 4-+
i,r.ritilq JrL,-Jl a-,-u! cv'GJl .1'rt: ^;gLi 1lS'-1 s* &-,rL JJri'-lJ
ia+''ill ttlill lr. ^r;i ,-r! fuJl li'o.r* a;ul EJUI c"-i JiJ \1vo iiJ ot
"+rl :.:-ll rl EUJI ri .st3;Jt ;- LJi.-,'"'- LJill 't't.,.,! alL-,rl - 1 : <!tJl
LllJj.ill r.-J 1..l)+i+*r. -,--. i J"h,.r'i: Cf 'l''q &Ji'-ll ii+ LriX
d;-Js.-'(1"1 tj! c,l3,i- -*:'c ",'.1sJl ;r {'Sl'':-il ;'u ''ls' ji t'r '}i ri--Xl
4i.=iJloL(|;:-:;Xl{jG-si.',-crgt!;1ol';-r'i''rr-ott-"<:-l$;8f3
g-L.Xl 3o ttEll ll!;L.3 cllr:-::!l ;'11 c'l'r., c'13'i*" -;L'J il"SJl rJl 6$ ir'
la-,J.rLJl i.--iill ;.r 6gsJl 6J oG;r''LJl ai'-i*Jl tili'Il t/l "'1^l ;
auiG tlS-=l ,:!r., s;-$ L.< r-i.: I t1-,X rtlt aiJ \ er l'.l: i Eit-.'." Jl-ls
;r,f.fl #-ll ,.1! )ii \1vo ;"" 1 ot iiJ sjiLlL;rt'-11 i''6LJl 'e"Gll &Jl"'^
,--J*:ll3 5-itL eG.ill li, j3l+ gl .1e'r nJL'^iJ LLo *+Jl !F '!::l !3
L s.oj 6r'.Jl d csUl a-'..J <, r91 ;i - c-.! - t-'i-i; a" cs}s+ Ltlr 4'l C."
. Y,i+Jll ,r3 rJ"-3ll': f=Jt ,'."
ais-Jl
,:, 1 ,r .+.r ...u ,: ...1! o):.5!l rJ.ill 1L--3 3l5Yl ,r'lc 1)t1.!l 'u.,
'd3lJl 'r-.3 i^!l-1l!3
.i,K-:Jl +cLisi ,r-l,.l;-l a,Ul ;! :'t^
,-l-.-:: - Jl,3ll Jit-J ql;,0'!fl ,SJl cr"' q+L,rl'- 6:Ll3Jl ;! ;''-=- 3
(JL tt'ls.,Jl .L3,J*1 ,-r,r. \11V ;j-J YliY fJ 6'e'rJt 1Gl 6G &''tll il Uj
- te-! a1.=-,---ll a".-.,-:Jl L;4.4 qJ.ul ,rc'L":'-)l JitSJl 3-e-r:'- -;'ctUt
i;.t cl : - -. ... . (J3! a-$'ta+,urv, a,' il+- d,r'.rl ;t t"l;J! #l trltl
JGr ,Ls+* $1-:.1!!LL-l c.,.r.=:l ,rlt3 \11\/\/\ .r' irq:'t &Ji'-ll L.j)tl
-a;iJ tJ,.,-- L 4+-=-Jl &ijJt L;1'r'.' q:llJl qJ-LJl d'" c[ ol3'rJ'Lr ri
d,!-i JlrJr,-lt i.-iX r+ \v r.rul ,.J t-ii! 4lb ' Le'' dL'i'--il $lslt 1.1'ti'-''
Y. .. fis $.{$ cr4 y a.,A \\.t
}l .,JiLll .J- o-. ri & J.-- 1l s*l-Xl 4.i. Jf ti"J ir+; t . 4l* L , r
c;r+Jl tl-!l s e *, ira; +*.l;- 6J- d. i-, . : d.r.tUt 6L a+. +a cl
!-rl :r.:,<- oe$ ls.,J ,.rs't*1- iX-ff .1t'l:.JrJ..tl ijlL* all rtL.:
J-:-Jt i+i+ tyv,A. il*- o.r; O.rt J 6.g;l ,.1s.tUl rl-!! tr11/"/y1i+.-.ll ,-$_i.ill L;.r"1 ql.l_..l! .r"cL":-:yl J-it<lll JJJ,r,,- d tslr,ill .rc d
dr -ilxi-YL l.rJ.-.1 -l(r'.'r...1 i-s-- 6J f-JI lj.a,;"ctUl -it'rj-l .-Lri_L
J,t ..-iti.iJt fJl s--_'r:. i"S=ll c,"<- \1q1/t/y. g_rE..r. J V', ,jJ At1
,J63i" (9iJl l0r i c,+l !JSL. itill r*,$3 ,,.ri:ll ,-!J*A #Jl lJ.t (J_i L,ctLll
i-.L,:.r,r-.-i ,Srl-ii i_iJi d i*(sJ.l oii + ;rLll ,;; ,{j.i irJi,tll f<Jl
l41L Cl+ll .-..:'rll 1.0-^i- ,,,,rh.'.t
irirtiJl !i+l"i (J.i il.r ll 4.!i i*Lll f<.Ll lJIc ,_,cf!Jl oLri, L-. ;! ,..r ^.r
eq,-./l A-S-- 1Ll <r.G.r,rn d.*i 4il JA cff: af* .,;s ,t. .itl sJ ,r.,-ilL
e.+"- rr" irg; i..-r-1. (l;;f* U 4.S Y! djJi,-ll &,-i-:-,J y o,.:,."qtll ;L
ftlill J*.*-n 6LL \\1r iiJ yrv fjJ JIJJI i: :.r^ c,1r11,1g s_t*ll .,.,Jtl
4...*.,L iJ ^ . U ,r.j,-iJl i._xr"i qJ.tJ! r-till q*iJl &JiJ .-L,_.jl
\11r/\ \/Yr .Jj i^''ill + !6JJ LJ,-II ii1{Jl r-,l.rt . *l- u-,r_ J (J..Jrt. r;,
\1Vo ijJ of pi.; oritiJt+ !1,-ltr i,-t!t i{-Glt G-.,Jt:. 4iG pL(-y iurr.r...l
le i.<rrsrll l-{li+--t r,n Yl L{.tL,.i: rJ*ijt j!JdJl... U.,tt:tj++l}6Ib
].J*-l lil=. JL-i;! dl.] riJ 4+,.1..11t r<Jt di_t .lb .+J,itxt {+,-iJt
Jrri+,L+ 1., ii-il q,r'iLUl l.i.i tls--! i_ijHti.L+ cs"ll \11\ ij*t \A f.iJ
.4;$ .r.s. . Ji,.-,-J 4!! 1.. dlj
"!i
gu.rJl l.$ ,rJc .lJi ;l .19.r ,..=Jl
- i"<sll oia ,l- ': r.r, -.uifl aK U +,i cl.i .dr" {r.i urtll lsa;l e"f_,c
61 1;+Jl ,r*A L+rl! .=.ll.*r t l.;Jl il-- 6.rJ o ,rJq gti.r <--. 3 3l -Jt ;[ ,rl
6i iJ.f l ,rJc rri_, rsJ,aJl ,rn 6lrJl +--.3 r:+: =.iri,ll ;r--* t+ {+ J.,^il
;tS3 ,+;i; i'.*.'r-,-L,-!l & ur.- l{ <^ .l+l yb t-"l_i. !ili*.C <1.l" er+J
aq e-€rtl iX-- tt"i <-.Li.r,r3.'l ..^: riapltll &rt.^tl ii .,,.Jl s.t c.itj1l
l. . . tua J'sar q,a V t''tr
p-rlj! r't-.,-l .lJ "a*'ull .,lc 4-ft-!JJ i''J-'-ll i'j'-'-dl i-ll'r! g+J+- ld- 'r
;, ,,. -rr ,r-.t-'ll ptti;ll , tr+-; ,-,"r-i \ \lY {iJ YtV i3J rl'i*ll \1tY/\ \/Y\
ai,,lotf-,nr,6Lyt'-1li''-t--llr-y'uJl&J1"^;r'il-3tSl"..rl-(JJc
: a!f:!l {1+l:Jl !1.,/l ' ir' :;! .,.L tt!:Jl lir r,,a a:."t!l Eotll c..'-l $3 \lVo
i.r:l .,a-,rf '.? Jl rl atiJl 31 'rctnll i''-'L''li'+-'l i'J-ill 't'cnl ilL; - 1
g- lr ,irrt$ F. t n- ir+-i.r*F" -pJ J't': +"t et+- J.l:ti & " ll t>lr
.,<] lu c-.ri oa-,| lib ']l$*' J& al9 &$Jl (Ji 6lijl i's j!; xi l.'ri't
o.ra ;s in=:rJl .:L(l';'iXl <]ti'J*!'6 !-' eti:+ c,lJi-' -*itc i's J"S:--l $
,-t' u,L-'dl si ltLill li'a;L3 ell-r-l-''i1l ;'+1 ':l'r., 'rlJl- '-l'-'l iL'Sil [Jl
-,l;n ta-,.;aLJl i-=-:Ill arJ 63'nJl 6J ol; ,''lrt'X ii'il1 lilll "l ""i-l
i,tt! tK-i ell! -;3i tl J-jrr I leX lltr ai*J \A fr l^r: 'l 'Eil---
;".rtll fJl Al J+ \ 1vo :" ' "t o I fJ A'JPtilL ;'rl'Jl i'-LJl ;p'utl 4J['
, 'o*--.:JlJ e,--Jl-, gLlJl l& ,-t E+ Jl &rJ djt ' '?l LGl 'r'-ll 'r:ii 'is:l 4*i
L .5o3 <sJ'cJl d 6Lll 4-. ., q 11t.,1 al - e- '/ - d'd '-1' rs,l'6J + 1ti'r <rl g..
i,,tll +-. gl gfl+ ''^ rt i+t- ,-rl'r l-'iii '','-. . 3"3 :"+Jl !i .l'' ' ^Xt #Jl *+.il-!l Fiill g'.rA,JI ,,J'
المصدر: منشورات قانونية (manshurat.org)