تأييد رفض بطلان أمر تقدير الرسوم القضائية: المشرع لم يستلزم ذكر اسم رئيس المحكمة أو القاضي مصدر الأمر.. وخلو أمر التقدير من اسم مصدره لا ينال من شرعيته أو يمس ذاتيته

t r r r' i.irr.r J,L/r't'rJ i' t agrlr

i.rl ..ll i,-:-;-cs ,L.sJl ,r..!- J iU 6+dl s-,*1 /rl r' 'r ' (l ri-Jl i-U.')P

.AXJI oiJ-L,i LtrgJl .l.c3 6eLJtJ+ '''.+ uiL* 'Guti':Jl $r"/i t '+': "U

(Y.1)

arsL;ill lt al..J 1 'Yl fJ !*bll

giJEl .rry4l iyJlt rlr! 'r.-i[r3i"'Jl d: 19' r rl Jt3$l) rit"t-"'l (\)

.f.r .< i.o3...oiJl 'rtislr

6n-r .Lr*-Jt .rt!r:l .-,8$l eb <s3'Jt &3-'''- gl'r'-! oi.: L3'-..Jl 'q

r.;.s '1J,.- t-e u++ll d" ..J:1 .rr'r''!l i:5--1 '1;3:Li q'ls ,ra'il| AX-l 'l'oi)Ltli

.5J,4Jl r[il iJJ--fl i"-J.Jl ;ltli;lt-! 3l ;]Lel ,re'r o5;. 'r-:-J dJl i*J"ll

.c)te! i-tr;.r .rJ,eJl f :;.rr '+r-'r i-! 't;ltt'l 'ot.lJ' 'e.,;Jl i LEJ dh'b

.(aJr. 16 l3,sl,) ly4J .f .rtu5$l *.tt3 {t'I3rtt crl.;lilh .;ti (t - r)

.n-itill f- .tr--. r.. .1t(-Xl iF 1|.r&l! .* rl <{'rll elJlJ'ill r* 1 (Y)

ta-jr\:;,| . Lgl.r,-! l:lJ" ,Flill rir-4 !3 ;*i - k.,]l*= 1" A'i- yJl €'lJlJnl (Y)

.rSLll Lat3r dll i.!r ' ':rl Jt"ctl iF

l:Ll- JlJ'r; ,,;till rl i-s-ll ;"J- -, >"! or.r-- 'arir ' I -'rl fg-Jl :r''ji (t)

.;)lL X -o-1-r,o1 1-l ;r 2si:ll ;*l sti 'UUgi^<^ o-,1,':'lat' *-"'

!l c+cJl ij, : el .,lc c,L*-ibfl ",iG.r."(rY) ;rUl "'i 6;j, - \

.$,:lUf ,.rel fJl- i'"<Jl :itjS ;Jr L"3, ia9''-1 .rc'rll =Jt tL 'U', ixlJl

\\1Y i:-J YY eiJ &ititl{ ul ''tl irriLrll c,li; (Y/11) E'rtlL.3 'n" clli;i

,."I1 Jl I (r at^ . ^ J)l-c! X! rsuaJl (Jj 6ri'r" LJ"-ill -'r:s Y3'r : ;1 ,,rJc

f<LJl .3J Lir .::tl n+lllJl 'tr^. 1 i;l, drl ,Jc' JC *i-'lJL .';-'r dt- <. l'

. f-6*l LJ,-ill,Jy .rlJ+! ,.,i< CL .,i. r,J L 3't3 iXJl -bS fl3 t l:1^' ^ gl'rl

I. . ' a& J.lr4J u. a a,.dl:

f..Jl ;)ll! Li .LB+ LJ-.-!l .+,r.1-r+l _i',S +1" +_:+ U s^J i.SJt _tjs

o-LlL.: Le u)/.cl g:*iJl ! ..^: d Qu, *-rtt y.; .rc J-..u ,t-r3.! s&, te

irSU Of.i -r, ,r.G .cl ,rr... , <-cGr .r-., ,S t,,_rLrt i.l , - ll i*.LrlL.3 t+:" ,r"Jl

fe.--Jl rr- t+l+tl tLi ,,, u-r l41 *.l" ,,1" tSlS ll+j" e.Uj ;lS crl,aJl iii-.,-.,

| 3l cr -. r+ u,"i Ji d.*ir., Lar.L! ;.r ,- r,l r:,t ...taJl ,,.! qlc .r.dl JL ,l_r* Q+

cs:c.Jl $X i.r'- ll i-"Lll - Jt! .r)l-,! ul .r),-l ..rr" _ -G.= l.ib .,1,_,-i ...J:.=

*c..rJl 3#+-- u+ill i-"lc {,- +* t"? to;cff ; LLlr,5",'r3 td,t. ,ldl J;.

i..(:ll o.l.a ol . :.: c, r<-)+ f ,rL, - cJJj ;lS ;itill o,S>-.,r l.61, ,rc. l c,t,.tl^*

.+:)lc!;.;Jl $ si ,r+Jl . ;-J!<r t i:L &J ('raJl J!.i j r;Jl GK _

r.o i.:1. i:!l .15-/l ;,.c qjul Ji. Jl ljyJl c,lJlJ-ill jer.j ,r.i FJI _ y

;,-itill l.(=

fJ--Jl 4iii .,.i nJY: iL1-; d L"?,;Gll b',, ^: ,rXl J,.b.fl - y

.,,&-s t, d-r ,14l.l ^! {ltl-* s;LiJl , i'.: .,.r yr +,_". r,-: y:,:+*- c.u.r.r

ttrLi Ld ,r. ^ rl JljilL f<tJl t-6yrJ (Jjll i_-,jt .: itl JL^ .yl ;c . ir: r.r

df-r. .,jl . rill rl^Jl l{:J,},t .^ 6;J l(... ,, .^, L.,; ^<- .4!, l+rl+..,-l

;*?l ; ta-;19 *L+ | E.r,- ^ c,t,L i,-;:_, ;i c.r,.,tUl -,,. . r.lr Lir. u.jr . ^r

.

.,jYJl Jt'Jt o-l# $. .r-LiJl ; r,rr . ^tl

pr--!! c,6l rll \1tt iiJ 1. dJ;it_!Jt .r" (\1) iJUl "6j 6,r-rr_. _ !Jl a.SJl r.rd-.r g. -r.r--:,.r-! f.p,rll _rSj, : ,i ,r.lc J.dl i.;"rll .rl.i,Il .,j lit .::tl,fJl t,u a; -. JL"I J.?l Irt :J,.-: -b(t ff, .,1t,+ .Ir,. Jt -Jl .:...,- .;GJt

i ";UJl ri i"S--- ua!- J cj. J.r-.1 fq f,: tJil;ll ;+_.:Jl -ar!: ri .,L J+

,ri ,.3lre'*! ;1l:Jl ;L(j ,'trL;! 't <= i a,- 'rri ),t_i r,,,-;t+ Jt A.jyJt 4..,Lt- JtL,:-Jl .r- dXJ r.fl eiJ*ll ,,.L_,,^$g!;Jl L.._.r," ijl .::rl .,_Jt r$: >.!

;;U.j t_Ftl rjtl-r C ib ,i--jil i-SJt -ES di yJt,l",t+ A-<J| !,.,j- r

".G

,*"'il -,,.^'^ ,,;Glt Jl i*(Jl c.r*- r 1-l _,Sl irl.x)l l1i: ^ ijl . ritl p_Jl

.d.,llj o*- Jl ,:,.r,i Jr" Jq y o.) ,. ^,. *1 ; ,,,,r!Il _yT 3L

Y. . . :Us Jr.aJ rJi { L!+

aiS-atl

r.!ll Jl .i.':...t1 ,l.-,-Jl o)j 6il! ;"Jill gL*3 6lreXl .rl" Elull .r-r

. iJ3l Jl .r^.,.3 i*!1-;tl3

.i-.K.lJl +"1 .^ri ,isr-l ,',rUl Jl ..!^

"l-.--; -;l5Yl ,,L: o:i ;"-ll,! f<Jl n +iJL" ,i" - i lll Jl s..=- ,

;roGll .-,.:+ .,E crrL..: \141 a-:J \ . \f *r 6j'c.rJl plnl cctul 'tr..t1 O1 ,

.<Jl : i..1. ^i r .;sll ,ps')S; i;rUfl &$ J"Li Gi.,.-r o.G,.s,rtll r. 'l-eJ

,<,L,i \1Ai iLJ lY a-i r rcrcsll ,.s r.llJl i,:1. ' :!l 1e-,Jl p.ri: -yl ;)lJ.-I Jw

;1 ,Jl i.rr .', ..,t ."& J ;< .rliiib J*Xl lii ,Lilt Gt+.-t, ir-al-lJt -,. ;+ ,r]s

..r.".r oe.r-l 6Jl a-(Jl , ".r3- -r ,rl ' "11 1-l ; l*lL- ,.r.,- .6JSi JUI ', ':rll ''"1

"F ,;rl! f<- q,E "i J,"Vl l.r.a;LS li! ,;.uil| r,ti!-iill r-il-,'*s o.;ts,-.| gzl:

.5rEJl j f-ll ;i gc'lt;i.c>tL J! crrr: W! ,Hl ,:L$l +:e.;:1.r

L+{-! ":L ,.rcJl 1t.;J,t ,r;-3 ,#J.l f+-Jl _;$: _.pl LFL-j- J, ^ .Ft

c,.S.= o>F lusl ;! .u,.3 ir**i i-"<-f t c--n .;cLUl .'l'... ll &.: .rl i.rJ . .r l?

lJ-a {.i1,^, o.r-,-o..rs*Lll .-ii'r-]*"| .

tJ-Jl 2S -xl ..1}J.- \ltY/\\/vt g.:uQ

L-J--,. .3 .E -oGll .-il'.'.'i.,.t a-s-- (JJ J \ 't ;iJ rtt\ fr -i[ii-Yt i<Jl

4l ,i,l .L;rL,ll u;iJ.,.r.-riijJl +Jl ,lil!+ L"<.=11 .-..' t \t1Y/\Y^

6'rjl lt : I oql iJS!. LlJl Ll3ll c,c.r3't3 uAirl .r,rf" a<-ll l.ra ;,9tUl

aJ.EX A-^b c's.s-i E rr-ii. A-iJi ; i-"S-11 (JJ.e,"!ll ,;r. lb ,J-tll lJFeJl

t{."|Jq$l ai:ll L*i-r

;.*Ufl f<-lt .,.l";ctUt .'lt.ll {,,,,+ r-lr.+- .,l" eil ;*Ul .]l '.:-J

iJ 4j! JA L^.e.bi ;*,r".r ,+a; .," .:llir {-n+Li ; I Lr lb iunlill i-ilLi" {-,-i

,',^ e,oe i.-JJl 2...,,ti,',L;;.ll i:Jrll Le,-:r- .JY -iL::*"f,| a\.-.,-;)tU-

(Ji 4-iJ j j3-. Yr .ii=Jl Err',-r J[-1 ; t-(j$l :,-,Jll +ljryl LrlrliJl

C.--.-Il jJGJI .r+:" j', , f-ll 6r,cJl ',+..s 8Ji-i J)U ts r<"-q fri: i,9<.

l. '. iia J&r J. t la.tr

g$l L r.^,.* #Jl d,i;ll :!e .QE i."L 4.r E.r.r.-ll i..ul c/ p+ al .1),tLll

Ji- .5.r:l i-,LJ.-itiii-Yl iii.-.,- J.,-L ;,ct!l fhjll .r)-! .r"r-.& Jr3

.{+J"i ,r3'rl"i"tJ ;:till ;!lt= Ji au<j {j!i .')t--l ar"-- enK ujjl

c,L.il Jl .',Ol-3,'* (lY'l i.rtlL, Jl .',,i clli . rrr- r,i . -'Jl lir.',1 i,-.... o

yL]S + e{. {i1.-,.1.f.,rl Jt,rL 'tj" i-.S.11 ;l su4Jl ir,, ' ;l uJc

ijl .:rl &iLill .:,,1i.1. (Y/lA) 3.r[IL.3 n... .lli ..le. + urtr| .--,r C t- iX-ll

Gu4Jl ,,i E&i'ri" i-J..,-Jl ....i-'l YJ, : ;l ,rJr. \tlY ii*J YY iSJ,j3:l-!lt?

"l-*. ? til .:l * Jq .-{*J+lli F-i il L {..L. (J4rf l ;t t, :r. ^ . ^ ;}/s,L Y!

qL -,]. Jf; L ;os i.SJl -,ES ,$ tl:i,- . elJ*! iSLJI 6.tl i,:l . 'tll iJttll

iJ JE Jt-&. .lr+!s+. t 6-, r-Jl ;]te! Ll ,k+ Lr--Jl ,+ jL+! i'<

;*-ll L-J+lL.s l(., r,rc.Jl c,l rlllJ t.',g., c)tc'! L-r;,lt ., J,-i 4l i:lbJ 6J,cJl

'$.r eili;tS cucJl i+.-.,-, L.e,6;Jcl;o;!i .cl,s-..3 *cG.r -r1 .rS LtB;l

.,+ trl".*.rtl ,-F- "lJ-" l.61i 1+,--iJl i11 4{+btl tl-: il o.r t€+.J",}'t$ts

rrrr - r,;r lib .')l--I &* | sl l.ic .,..J+ A.f 31 a-,ni" L!};l lJJsll c,l ...1+ ll

Lti" ,9qi3 I e rL ,ldl $c 6J$Jl ,!it ;.r.r - r.l , ...1i tl - ;ltt $te! sl $s!

o.1S..p,.3 l43i.p.rll crlrlLu gi1call Aj;+r uit+ll c-lc <*^l*t t+ a.1..-Jl j

,g,t

"/ -;*U i*-aS - iS.-ff o.ia .L.A-l +, .rJ+ l- sJ.J - ,:,[i JtS diLillqLiJl 61,53 .cllj;L< U .l:lrtc! "+;-ltl pJl sl ,r..rfl . irK:t i.'L aJJ cir4Jl\\\Y/L/i i-Js., .-iti:r-Xl i,s-- tLI .F...,.1u1 .:li.ll ,;c.;,:lJl ;1 ;l5Yt1

eJbJ+.r. taJiJ,-itnj-Yl ai+.!,- n)ll"t le : r 4r.r <-G.r, erSi- a$,

tr-3r \t1Y/\ \/\ . . \t1YA Lra--+ i-.(Jl f t-l , L.:rl .r3l- f .i-.J-Jl

Lsi+.1 "--i-lr-ll "sLtJl "lrrll + 4j. u1"+ 6ill J,."Xl ,+.cG-r. csr-il aJ.Si--

Ji L e.a.,-,J {i+.-^,4il14! Jc .i+ L 3r3 .ai e l-iiLiJl o_,1S,p3 ;L:f i-tl

#l ell ib ;.-a-,- L'll.^Jl +, Jiri:J J)U^, d. in.--'-ll oi-o ,.,Li ri i,iSJ

..,.1-l .1-"

"1".lr': d. ,_*,tt aF uLlt li.o qi ;U*LII

a.ri,'rq.r.ttl l-(JI +i.l.ll ti-dF;lill ,3*lt!,rr..1 actul ,! '.r^,,

Y. . . 2i.{ J*uJ ip t ilJs

)Gi ijr .:;ll try-lll .lrni G; ,;L tt<'11 c'UltJ i^E:Il 'rleIJl ,{ d "i

l.,jl .::ll {:LL., u "iLi .;till .r.6,,1.11 ' ll ,L,a3.ll JL'l .,' t"{il fiJ 'iEjEIl

g* o;tj-c.11 L- qJr.,.oi .5il1 u;till f-l ,it..ti pt-a t- ,pf-,$! i-S- U";;3

'l^orl" +,,i- 'v 'r.;-" eJli ;3'r tLo--: 13 L33'-Jl olrlrill

e-. Jl Ol t.SJl di! sl -:?./ rr"ll .11 dli ,q.u;i . a:ll lia J! ''r-t

,jlr ,,litill #- +^ .JUilt pt5.*'Jl ,c i.-"yJl .,i,-.,i rl {t3Jl c,l-;l;all -111; "/

::+;.rr"., fJdl i+aa .,3 A,i- IJ itl- a," 4l I ^a r+till L4.r-1 ,rll .;"leXl

JL"cXl ,.,p. itlr,r4-i f rr.,r , Lr-,;l,r,oL ':t^t ' 6;till rii:-J YJ q+s irrs-i X

t r i-(-. i:+ L{.it..-,-f it;U t l .uJl .l.LuJL #LJl UYrii Lpl i.il ':ll

oJ,,till .,-. . J'lJ iiur." L,..:l' r ol 1(- r. il ::U Ja,Jl le u'iL c;J l(:' JJ'.r

{.1+ Jr" o;tiJl ;r.;rl- l J"ll .,i LaJ,ilJi fit],,,i d r.r.r-* c,bl*.;^;:,;l

\ 1 t t iiJ 1. fir irritiil ; ( \r) i.r[t "Jl ;153,dli ;tS U ;&ll JL.Jt

,...r"r-,-: -r! ls-.!l ',;s-lin : 6l ,,Jc J",-tt +jsfl .rl3ll ; a;t :;tl l.r-JL

J,Xl li^ aJ'.,J -E<Jl + r,lt,.,J" "U-, JIJ'-?| ':""^ d;till Ji i'SJl o"-':- J

g." rJ-.,-i J-"q *;.il .::ll tr-;ll :r!i "l ,r-1" J+ ",-,./l lii {i' -.Jt-"lli<- d;. 11 )-! lryr'L ill i..i- yJl 6tl,- rru,i d 'Ftill rl i"(Jl o+J

,-u- $gl..;r.ll Le;s i,ir '':r1 fs-.,;,ll :ri:,rl;l 6lrel! .:.,t:Jl 6L(3,iJt'::

i.-S.-ll .,ES#-JL.,.t ,l;a-"5J1 ,;,.-- ; .r=,-.,JI & ell.lJ r--Il 6'tJ '1ll .,Jo

1.,l JSi 6Jt.ill 1$:. i.!r .::ll nr*Jl arl; "t Lrdl fill-"J d ib ,i*riill

JQ 1 ".;,r,^i' 1-l .JF J.,rEll >"1 ,/i;!i ..;.11 ',,r-,.o. .,;till Jl al.-fl u'...3- J

.,L-! Ji n_1S3 JliJl li-r 1+i ai,J.rl #l fll ib .{+li u-!l rl +:pr;;,.

.,-*t-l * .,! {r"} .,4Xl ,r<r s ,.g;GJl gi--

. i,tll . air +.,+ ;.rE UJ