تأييد حكم برفض طلب عارض بدفع مبلغ مالي في دعوى إشهار إفلاس: مهمة محكمة الإفلاس تقتصر على بحث توافر شروط إشهار الإفلاس دون التطرق إلى الحق الموضوعي

t1t

Yr r r i-igr Jlogj.l d' 1 a-,Js'

!.r&3,ilJl ,,.Jr..-t-l 6'l,.' ^tl a"^-'1 [L':;Jl 'q '''!l i*9,

LJi p:Jl,s. 3 6JL. ll r+ ,...,. ;.c ,.rL,-a--" .4lilrll s'''-' fu-21 'i t 't ! i'JL4ll

. a"SJl u.,:- J -li

(\^t)

ar3r, rart 1t afgJ YAl\ lasJ id.J

.ej*3jfl i-oSro .<g*)li'Jl $.ill gll)ti! (1)

4r rliir; L- .o.)t-i?l ..*.: ci-:- Lssll J.,Jl rri iilLill !J.- 6J-;1$:

.ilL--ll"l.rJc La't ':c-Gl ,r- L-";./l i.S's-

.r.t3,irJl ;*.,.,ri: d t(-'Lr"' :65lll .,Et*"cr g3*;3rt'l 46s$ (Y)

ol..j; L- c,lr,-llr e,GL$Yl r*uu s:cJl ,ri ilJl f'{-i AtL Lr;rl! L"SJ

<Li-: L..c 6;'iJs a.-i-iL- 9L*l ,rlc Lvr .' : prr c.,ri -{t}:r ' t.e'!3Lc + rlll iJI

,,:!l q$Jl .r! 1l.rL 6*. . .r fr--!t JUii Cl"+ l+." QJ. tl-.;ll Y 'r"41 c'l;15

.Lal.s tl L:...t.| ,rr.Jl Jll 161' ^lri "l

.5- .crlS! .(o")li!l 6;3s,rr g;3ca (t ' f)

ilL c.,l;! l4i.$ ol'llal gJ..r,r-o L.]! 1-3'^ 6s-o o-':l g'")till cll"'r (Y)

. ra!3..p rs-:,r:- iq'r- 1$jE {l--;J4 rb el; ,JP J-'i"j$ u")t-i}l f- 4!'*

Ji +t:llr &Xl L.-u;,',-r,tll tlilL L;JLJI a'btul L<J-*iJl ':'!L (t)

.6rln .i-+lnJL.iJ,i. Ji" s"+;s'.9- !ll!' l-L-l 'q'" gt= t."+l U+

J...,!11 #Jl rlj:ll .,.'lli iL .u.)l-!Yl i.S'- i'{* nc JUt l'i'a i' J'^il| 5.'r'ri

.c:*,-. SXI li'6 +

1... ii..J+Aiji i.1 a..A

;iJl .,-i a4.1t.itl q.r+ cE- ';;"-ii;l- i-"S-It o.ia .L---!; - rAl -\

Zr;Jl i-<-J t# Jt:iJl "!+.rfl J:LJI ..,. rr,.,rl-ilt 15urc., ci-i Ls,..r'Il

.4IJ u-iS: iXL- vt+-i .,Je L*l '':;*t!i ,i la1lc rrn* \

;, ora,Jl .,+ ilrll i6s,s" Lult iLLJI 1.;r-;.rrtl a^<J;i -'Jill - Y

la1"it + ,Jl .,.iri 61J: t.., e,t';.;Jl JjL-r eGLlj)t \+"i:r dlJlb llaXl ;.rni

l(J!. ,_;ijll a-s--t LLir &.r le a.JLr,_<.r'cJl 65ii3r' r1.q:--" frJJ,,a-!.i lJ3J'rJ

d c;tSJ ,4J^J . iS: ixL- ilJ+i. .-1. "i .r.,lc. La.t ' :: e*t!l .r-3 c,"l'r L etli ;

r'+.r. Ljll ,11-,-+.r ,l+,l.rlt" 4LL-i 6ill ,..,'-Il ;c.:,1;'=11 ..2..,*c,rl CF

#llii . ;!: I . ; f{-+lr 11 c,l.ri:-" .r- t+J 1e-.--Jl 4-r+ L. JS .1" .r.rlti

l{r . ^!i.t ...1 ,Jl ui3Jl rt+ Ll ats "} k} Js ,J. l)l-i:-l "rlt: rl:. . s

. Lnl.p l1 L!*Il r.].Jl JJI te t: t.r c,.1gr"l.r

Jb A-J"-i 1si1,-.r c*"J t<l*$:,*.--., u.)l-ill Jt{.i! 6.ea.r ai -r-:-!Il -Y

Jl I -iL JJI ' -U #Jlr i!-..-- AL-,:,1-,r! Jr-"- r;l! ; ' e ': c.,l'l-r+! L<rrJ rl.i

i.n- JiL! ;Jl- J,rii ,rL --.--:+ JslJ .tlJJ "" LL.nl )L'-1 a, .u^! \] "-)Llll.

't

ol.-.-l -;i-': .-r- i+r+

L-!,G axsLtl fijJ! iictUl L<y:Jl ". 6dl ";rL,Jl -JUl ;15 ll -t

r.r.e;*. ,3-+ Cltt- 3,a dn-1 \ t t 1. \ dlf +-i^L:i. td t- + al a,jLlllr *Xl

yls, cE.r- '.-'. ,J4 -!.-:n: u*)l-i!l L"<-- i--e* r,jL{r ,i-"!i]lt;qlrl- J+

I'ra .lc 6i1 L.;! .-!-rHl ;r9'r L.-a'r'; ,'Lq,tll ,+i<-FiJl cr)l-i!rla-:r! t'r, ';

t.i^ {,i,',--tll #Jl fi:ll i! ,,fs;-r.}- .,-i E"; r! a-l>,- Ll,-i'll rl Jtul

.;ril-iJt g..-,- 1r1l r3,',-+ 4iF ys,-i,,r,Jl J-- *lUl JrS p+,.s.;l:.ltnll

ais-aU

;,.,111 ,t .:.: ...t1 ,l ...!l o$ 15Jl -eJ-!ill gL"*"3 6l5Yl ".le 1)tt)t ,u.

.il31 Jl .u-,.3 A^i1../13

l. '. L-J:|.iJje,1 trj5 111

.i,.lLl,ll ccl .-.rl ;.y-l ,.,,U1 ;[ .":^

- 6ls!l ,,,l-.,-r d.n-i Ar.rlll l(Jl ; g*.-L- .,L - iLlJl ol i,,..-- J

G;j*+ll cF,)l-!t \1At iiJ o. fl:6r,.Jl c.-Gl aicul i<JJt ni (J-i J,-_-u

(iri) #Jl :,q i.rLJJ Axt L.-aG;r.!rl3 Gr--11 u-)t*?t J,-i-i dl+

iir.lll c,l<J.i.l! ,tiJl +ln" {.1|i t+ \ ! t .1.1 6Li" t+.1 or.! ,jq J,.# "\ rl,,l!

Jts,rlil 6U-., ,L*J-; i".,l,Il ,+i<Fl "")Gl .rl'{-ij! (ql6) .('rl4Jl i+-,-,

(JJl l# J.r-

"_,ttl

.a!+lt -ilL- itlt Axt ta.G;r,,ul i<J*:^u axlJ l+!

c*L!.i i=;lill ta-G ar,,-tll A.S_.;.:J! ; L.r,.-.-. Q; r-. tt.j,L"iJl ,Jlr-"

t{n$J ,:',I+.iJl 6i.6 (J.i JJI A.lL,', t"-oG ,j},.tlb tJ. -,. J,,,Jl .ntitl JIeL

nj,lll i-ti.;,1<+;.!l a,j3,-dtr ll.)tLil ,..t,r -,. ieei-r. li k!! La;l-.G.,tr:.tt

l-6l3ls.l;i ."1*+ll i-lll- c,l..ll^lL 6r.Jl c.,.GG .*-EiU i-LG G_ r All toG

q.l+t -u ^i,r,!11 -..lLll 6e tCJt-.r,-l-:,i.'rlJlidL LJ.r6:.j1 'lrit.:r.r!

.,J3YI Lal; a".'Lll iS*iJl c,6-'. 3e , Lr,:-- ,'Lq,l".tl ,:ri<Fl ,_,-)U! _.,t+il ..,b

.:lSyiJl .rr., Ls-lrl .,.!Li. i,iEll LaJ;;J.tIl aSJ"jJb 4lctul .r;, i.rc- _.1,i,<;cr

!it-:,ll taG,',r,,lll 6./Jl c,ri.r .t+l! Q-r-,h- u iJ.-Xl Gr-cJl t+'L-t Ltill

i-U" a;Ut iSJ-,jJl r,iL;l f.,rsr-.rll A'tiL- i-^(:Il ..r-r . .:11,.!r,

.:rl<t i.ll i..3 Ql l+.:! AL c-.t . :," a.,rtillr Js?l 1"l-G nrelll ft-rt! ltFl

\\\./on. e,*,E -.<* o--;i: g.r3i ;i .,,.3't a5 aX--tl c,,s . t-6Jl AIL-il

6.!J .i-,1--- 1l csl'rJl uJU,., .,r-)*Yl J.,-+ dtt Jl.,-3 i-J-,.j,Jl .l-r oli!

,.sJ3Xl ln, . I ar-lll a-<J-,ill #i a'q ii.,tUl lSJ*iJl rljJL A,-,-.,J-ill (sr,rJt

;$liJl -ilr'.'t...1 a"S--.(,J l(JI lri ircttll c,iiii-"| .,r.lrjJl L.r-.rr. c_,t<-,.;tl

igl ;)tLr..-..' I \11tl\/y1 g,;L_i,._r .J \.v aiJ yyl^ *J.-i1..'. i ,.,)L

*,U A il!^ ^ t=.,,",!i L"S--" o-r . ^'trl fJ-l (\) i""--.r .::tlJ -ijijJl

isJ,.ill u"y-i! Jt6-":r! +L ";l* (Y) Lillt Li.G &r,,-Lll aSJ*:Jl u.)l_it rt{ .nt'y-<;, ai"utt <rJl .* 6dt r;Jt-fl :,lul &$ rJ+ (r) Jsxl 1^r.:;rrlll

{s}iJl J.;JJxl L6G;.r.ul 6-:Jl (J.{,+l L;Jt ll JUI &+rr'.,.r (6)

Y'. ' ii4 Jrat9 oi 1 a"'ls

,o:iJl ;q,J.tr #Jl tii .,-i irrtUl rJ.,! ')lS'i 'rlS+ll ry I ( 'liJ!., ar'ctUl

.i-6 ,;r .Fi Jb ..i-!l! .,;i* ,rl-rll I r J i o+1 EJSJ'- LLJI qt$ll c'c'r313

tpl.., CI1..JI *r'll l+;- s iJtsI L'J.- e'r's! 61e'':''' i$i i i"SJl

,, r ar'Hl #l ,1" L{+L abull u:-', a**t" ,.rlc pFi ;rtjl ;! :':-"

.,-l rr",^3llr Jrji*Xl ,r-i lt*irll3 6r'aJl .,'i yl3Jt 6--l: J+"'--i ; ''Ill

i:c'l!llasr-Jlq,i:)t-J!r+:-ct+Jl;irrl'^L-+--.jii*-';;**+-'fl

aill ,J-,-dl r-3.c 'i'i,.r^'' c'i*:i:;r::*' a-'-L='' al)l-c "l3Yl Las-; clrtll'r

.(- ii'C csill tul Jl.,-rFIl c,l+l"c,rb *^l 'J++ uXi ..ri 'r'= .'" \14'A/\

,-/,.sei:,-,r <.-L.11 ;* {!.i,, '6:-!r-! !3'*l Lar; 't+rt asFl .1l Jul "'-L

!r..r Jl-,r fl +,1 LJ .i'-LJl 1ttr; ;rc ,-; oFl JLJI 'u-31 L'" ql 'r '^il J-''it

,t rJt ,f+;+.,]::L-X '-l:'ilI Y '\,r-'!,+:^ lrL t(-.,t' '-'--r-o'ill i:iill

rilcJ ,\\A.A/\ a-r-ll ,J-,i.ll $c 'l ' riiL LiiJ o c,LJJI o'u 'la::l ;i ''5c!3

rS.r! CL.:IXI i ra:-.r uPliJl Jl'rFxl a+ J''-i 'ri-r'r"'l .,i anttll .!- ''4lJs

,r.r3 l-a:.rl;! 4tL;. r, 4l)U.,.r eli 4lt'i-l fir t++-t'-t AXI La&i &'tll

,r...gls*Jl a.ictul t)n"l ;l !r $,-ug'r"rl #'ll .,al L"S 'alt+l "l1+ q.lrl

,i..rtl eli:-l ;'rr.lr .l.<!r ':Uf:;rS trr,,L'r;1 *r,ln'-''ll .-1lS L;! rcrJl

cli qrL --. $ ,k-r.,.s'iF4'rll a---'- .-''' et3"-! l(: 'i: iJ'^ "c a:ls i-r--Jl

.4,;!6 -'5. . Jl,-,,iJ #Jl :++ L +n: .|r.,,Jl ; C'+ll A'citXl -}il$

;i - a-SJl o,ir.L.^! i - rlill 31 ellj 'tt-e-':- r$ "'Jl I'u;! 'r''-- 3

,;l JELJI ,. si cr)l-311 lnrc.r ci-:1 Acairsll 4'rll .rs r'c;t]fl q"+ cs-:'3;

,:t+*i .,b La'L;!.:,.1!1 ,r- l'6+ +!..- \ LJ;rIl t.SJ t+:' 'J''-ltt "t' ri

6.cJl ,r-r dlrll f.s-s ; a-tlt auJl 33;sr! LsJ 'l'lJ '<L''J 'r'is ixL-

o:, J! .rsl ol;i t^' ollJl jL*3 c.,131il)! J+'-iir Jilr'lllr iJrXl -2$r q5ru

,;!ijl A.S--t !tr:.rr': L&iJA (JiroJl c,G.* o:''+:-'- lirr'-i+ is'to teSL"

,{LJ,r-i$ ijil- ilJ+n':t+-l ,.,.! La'L;! c','L3i '$ c-trL ':lli i L{+

LiC r+ r/l ,tet-r!" d*l'r 6llt ,r-''-rr ..'" c'l-;y'! '4*is '.," eF C t;15't

r. . . a*! J+aai d. 1 a4l5

#Gi . ttt. ^ .r" el*jii.ri i:l,li- & ld 1s,-!t <.,4 L '$ + ,Jl "+.r.I (: . !r'i ...1 (JJl ii+Jl f tj! d ,jts ,i L{j. JS (JJ. y)tJi*l ,_r.f ls r.{=_.__J{.-i,',+itfl #Jl ;L<3,etljrt.S l.l.l-nl.r I Lr..,U u&;Jl JJI ls t-.',r,r c,.Ur.b

., tt. i-Jti. "f-- 3,a r".r.Jl f-r-s- r:,tlyLIL .-.iUl .r1.Jl ;i !1 ,,^A r_a

<l'G+ll .," t+-tLl ;'rs Gl_u'$ ..,. L^Jj_ t_d *. l-6G AJ,III i<pl .,jL

LrcJ,J iX-i-- i:lL iijL;r..uL. ' . JL .S:* .-,c,.,+ y ircUJl 6J,-i,ll .,llJ! .+:ls ,Jt"t--11 :u+< rl ,jill rtiJJ t6i,:l; ci,l. +- LF,,r u t{jL:jl k -l]b3,r" ,r-i o.r_pi t-.r!*,rL .,J3?l L6", . ^ iu,lfl a<r.-i,ll .r.)tl! _r.l_ :Jt ,_;l-,a-iili-Jl isJ_.i.ll c|J ii)-nl i,..l'J 6l g!; L 6+-+ &. ii.i i6.:L_ Di,, i-i.,..L'* 6J-, g t\A. /\ /\ i.rj.f l .l-c^:f t r ia ...:,r.r .,J3?l kilc ._uijJb

J'rl l6 ,1. .iiii.Jl <J_-:,X i_ijti-Jl i<J_iJl ,-l_,J-:.*Ll .r! pj-ij::i.:... "? '::! l-4 ll . ..::b ;,.il| C- Er*irl o.r-r La ,;.j er. .:r-,t.,: LLi .rl Lf. y-,-p

fb.,JcJ+ L^.61r3'Jl .-.t: $r..1(.t.,,ijtll ;r.....tLEJt ...r JI 9._r;- lgc+ril"-'Jl i,-.JL EJt ... rtb C,.Jl .,3 L.et JS...,.^: q*:t r ^rru, i.,_,LJli.,-JL lr:r. .1-_" f k,+ J+ t-.r i.jElt I{,r. .]tG_Jl L<J..rlL qn-LJt

;lS3 \1A./r/\ ar_Jl .J.,-sl.ill JU i.,JL t<it .i,:[r il;.trifl L{n cE c,l-rig

+-J +-. J frrJ t{i "LiJl c,c 4iL -,. J,--Jl "ljall ei.l ri et<t].tl oj.o,.rl .-.ili.ltJj aiii-i-Jl L<dt Jl*sr ,rL ..L.d. 6_u,-I a_.-.,.J', cti._y L_ l{:.^ L_ i<J*iJ.,L-jl o.ra c,jl<;l (...J!.^.sJl .-._: \t^y/Vil\t p.,L:, c,r<,.;.r1 ctl +--l3.u. Y .rrill ,l!.i .GLr'rl r'" c+-_Jl f+*- kf; SJI ,Ei Jt -l i:Gtsr ixl_ibll r+l,J er;rll ;-s--" iLL ,r" '+#r- i.s oL'p alu;;r<-;l

i-5=- tl-i c-rE! _19+: Y 1." l€ * iiibfls tlt; L,rt! dr?l .r,,:ir .,r,cJl .,.i

.u:ixl

J*J'l ,. lLr ll {ri d$iLI #l + ;ut +Jti .pt ..f,-L ;t ..:_,r

Jro p,+ 4;: +- ii.tUl L<J".tJl l.!- _.r.rt .^ jl .:*J". tll ,r_i ,J_-!b &iLXl

aucJ.ra r.I, L9,^- curcJ .1. -C .p)Liyl c",l,c.r,.11 ar^ -G_ + rstf+-yl t{,.tL

111 Y... aj4J+Jj J.1 a-r5

a). , i,ii iJL (J_i J,-till Jt< lil l- (Jr 4]J,- dL crl+! J_r_ J! -i.r.6: c,l.l_.;:l

4tL-,:. JIJ t-_L-"J i.-L.,-; ...tLtl ,Jr+ t Lj .i, ni d+_ (Jr ,LoJl i). d.J,,J iJ

.o_./i:64-.,_,-; Js=..r pe g- tp tl;"ls rn (JI-'$ .,.rLtL

le..+rt :*"-+ cr)-iYl ,le .i.1 GU,c.r AI {JJj .4j._" J+i ,r, .*ll ,-r! .: -.r

ii1.-- ilL- e,la5! .r..4-. Jl -iJ+ .rl,L"-! cs+"" .,.^ 4 i_.3,.-i (iJ-c.r .-.... *r

}d.:,fl.e .gl;:tl .j J,-itl 1..,.-l <, ,r-,-A,-y cr)-iyl ,t * .;.1, r.:r _^rl l.(Jl.r

u;JLll JUI JISJ ,,:!i iL< U .l( l..rJ .i, , ii!: .,i. Es.s i.n3;G iJLs,_). +Lel l-_i+ al +LJtr J,lt L-^J_;,.LqrUl fLl! ti"Ull i=r_:Jl ,.6, iil,i.-CiJt,3Jr:- _)+i .,4.Fr_ r!-t +Jtt-.p i..,j._ \ r r . 1. 1 a+ q;I . . : .

Lr-)Lil Jt { 'itl l.,rJ '}. >glj ct.r- e- tlJ" r*jjj qr.,r-iyl a-(-. a.--{_. c,itsJ

i-|J.,- JL-ill Jl jtLiJl l.ia,r,e Cr-L Jl !i-J.Jl &.r L"r,. . i".r!ll q5r*:Jl

Jr+ p"t -.:ir JLJI l.ra +ri a.r-[ll #Jt #lt ]b,,f:;.:- 3- ; i, -. ^ 3i

,r+ -1" .,,ill ,'1l(-,r iuitill e*=.,- $ll J-i du<J {Jl_i'X:i,i cr,Jl Js_.:.tr^tl

-rr"L1

.,..,!l .J-iJ q*i pn: tI3