نقض حكم برد حيازة قطعة أرض زراعية: المحكمة لم تمحص دفع الطاعن بسقوط حق المطعون ضده في دعوى استرداد الحيازة لرفعه دعوى أخرى متعلقة بعين النزاع

Y. . . iir,, $iSl i.o lV 4,,/rfl

i.ruf i,;,.,ca .{X.-ll .r,,i-; jll ,r-'r!:ll .'*ls l^'- Ll':r ' '\l +Jl L-l-!}

LS-II .-,i- r -t,.ji .s.rJl ,r-,-, c'-.r.o , g'-.,,'- s1l L-t!l'r' '{l*'i l'r- /,r1,1 .r"r . "tl

. 'J:Jl r.4 -. Jrll JEJ

(\v^)

aiL;ill 11 a.141 tV'\ i5J ArLJl

LJ.i,,,i iJl, tJsJ .!ra+4n.ar-$',-o.$r.G.s a-rg.;it1s 'cti'r (t - t)

.,.i $,J45ll .aiLlll LiI :' ^ :.lrJ.r:Jl ,-r. Jt-cr lS'- 'rijl r ^t; 6f" s3 8'sll

.rgr..rJJl

. cllj oL-il;,. \/ttr.JJl j-l GU,..r3 iJl-dl 6..5'e'r qr' C'Jl .rl.r+ p' (l)

d.,-s;ll:*t 'l4L; ort,'t'1 .t:ilJ=,J" 'lricl C+ c8- &Jl J-L csJ''Jl ,r.e"tl e..r

L.!: ..lili-Yt .rjt-r^lL dlcJl l.Jis..Jil .Jjilnll 4l LaJr-i,rfl ilLJl cp e 1-u-r

.6-ll i,-L 6".rtl 6ll .u: ij$l sla 'h:eYl

6l r! islll 6rL.J.Lgi .r3'* .1 .c,Lil,y \/LL J[;; Fl J-l 6t-"r (Y)

t+ a.1-" ",:. J=

"1,--u

l(;1'': .l<:,--rr,-t ll ;Llc,r.le r.5l3Jl ':ti-vJt Jt^d YJ-t'i Gu'Jl (f)

Lrr' .,la s.r,rlJl e,)rl-.---Jl - L :':' #Jl .,lL 6r; o'r-;.g''tll iJ 'r!Jj'" JJI

arr.tLll ;l*i i-2LFlL dtc'rl !3n- qJil td.,J-9''l ;ictUl 'L-'t 'ri'c L-5r'-., 31 1l,Jl

.

il-^l iel. 1sir"Jl db d4ir '4tJ'i

d^ f.(+ LGf! sjri^ tl JJ 6r4J .,n -ilxi-"Jl i.S* tL'l ']btul e!'''1 (t)

,rJ" i.lrl3Jl c,\+-.Jl '..L l',' .+-c.r <ri;J 6;eJl s'i {i' bi'^+ ilr-iq oa; 4'rJ"ll

+t Jl t-.(-*i.rlilL 4IJ*jr A'rl e.ttLll-).rt-=Jl "-Jl HJI '$c la:'3 3l;iJl L,a

.4-4*s-ai ditrc 1.r.ca 6-s.rJl clli J! q-i irr"lll #-ll irLi;l 1'r '{n-r-''i #Jl

.JL* 'r,-ir Jrjl'iX lXti'

l. . . al4JJ.J,:sl ii lY Ldi

..;g'1 Y,.;1 (JJr, .rL,-iLll uJ.,G a,^ L i. ratll ; JJ?l ;Jiill u.i L,-.iJl - \

ojL-e.:l L: ... Yb .illi n+llll C*,.u L*+ ;5L+Jl 6l-.r ,r" .f"Il e-- ,rl

ul,-i (;l:,...i3 6JlJ - 11 6JrJ rH 4-"3.1 Ai .r.dl jJ..-. ! dl ulE J+ - -;;f:.lfa

(rc ;rJ-- t-{.]lJ sjlj - ll <11"- Jt -<:...1 up L *iJl La.p.n c,l;hc.y ,:lljJ .JJl

(Jlc ,l.ljrl e+.r.=,j-Jl &-L 6JE3J| e3,.r J! o"rfl i il L- lj!-a .,-ff J,-l

4J La,i ,,ll U ^-ll ip * irr, ,{-^--i EjtJ^.. i_^.1-; ,l--r.:!j rr,Li ,4:rti.-

1-E,.!-Jl J[-L .<:r.cJl 6r-, r>.-. ,r]c ;;t1JL1 ,terXl t r:.-. $i:,+ {-i aiLill

.,j-Jl J,-g eijcJl ei.t r+ iJ Ji iJl:Jl ,rlc;l3.uJl ,:-S I U A:

151 Jl illll a5Jt-r ,jr - Jl tll l.r.t ," - .r-Jl J-l ,srL"+ .r3--ill -y

t4-rc r__:.U. .,1" ;-,

oia L-13-..-,3i Jl -" - ulc 6.r_2l3Jl c,l i, . -: ll .L_a,_,J .,. tl^a r<.1-.rJl -y

o.l; ,r,rLll 6ir nli f. rr.J ,G+ll JL,-L iiL:ll 6rLeJl al,..,i; .u ot;rr-Jl

"b.i Ji4 iu3"-i 31 1[Jl ,]c ,rJc ;.r.,,13J1 c,)t1.-;Jl ..,t^.r., a(.Jl JL rc.pJl

aia c,iLS l.f! Ai.tul ,J.' ijl}Jt? <jLc.rl t_r:...61".-1. r+ l_{l A.$ A.irtUl

.f.6-.i]i ,4i.tUl *1" -,$ .ri eucJl

ALi i-"$fl f{.rsj..i LS.,,.. d/.ic'iLil ni JtJJll (,r eyl:lt 6L< .i! -t

..g,...Lll ; f{+ Ltill 6j':^tl ,r-r 6r-J i/) \111n/yA i*J= sn -itnj._yl

8Jt-r ^ U rl{j-l gue.: ,r-i o r . : ,t.rtll J-: L "i.,.,,J 6lf=Jl -i.ll* fe+iJr (ol;

CJill ,n" ttrv gl;ll q-c,rJc' i.5l3Jl c,)l+--;Jl ...L.irj #Jl ...tL,. s,a.j a.,.iJ

li.i ilrJ',:f f<Jl yJ!J! telid;t ..tt d,$jJ,rJsll iicrLltr.rt - ll ,r*jl

s-iEi:-Xl f<Jl) {$ J+Il f..tl ;i3..:l.r.i*; o.!-!s Lr or,ri,.i3 (,r:-tl

+'t c_rt+.- .5 *4.a:etlJl ('lr ".t-; i,,-tll (5JJs (J.i EJt r ^ ll + Jrt . tl

.{.ara6n cr.r d: ,iJt .lli J! r+ d (a;r. - 11 o3o ,r,l r;,+ c+; ejJl.dti1r,,-+ 'L.J"i^ irrq iribll cirJL- 5c 'frUt o:,t_i

1... a;d ,-Jisl Lr. I v L-b

a-65'Jl

,-3.11 Jl .i.: ...t1 sa-Jl ")E GlJl -'.J-ill 1L-'"3 615'Jl ,r'L 1}l!l 'r.il3l.rll ':".3 i-il-/13

.i-.K,iill c.l-:sl ;j*"1 A*Ul Jl -:*'

. Jlrr'rl JiL-r {"-:-i arJlt fill "'" q.11l-,+ - i rJl ;! e.,''--- 3

* rr+lr 6 ;.- \ 11v ii-J 1t o grirtl tl3l "G ar'-trl JI .,-i cL'-'-ji

.cl3.c.: ii.,.-,-. ,-i i+Jl i*lrl cFr',| i'tnJ -crt-^ 'r-;'' i(Jl YJt+ U;ctLll

Jrlr pt c.,;: ++3.1 t[el iX'-'3 'iilt^ll o'ra ,r'l +l p!-.,r.lr'-Utl trF 1.}r,"r

-!'-s- ,s+ J Yo aiJ vt d.r -iEii-Y! ul o'r';;-"rlll -ai:*"l '(Jir'cJl

.r>,-s.it'r,i-,tl #Jl .Li!!i alJl .-,;n \t1t/1/YV g,_lb'.s'(1r+"ll i':.tr-L)

l{*i.:+1E;L!f+Jlr:*.r!3',-!ill,}*,!Sll.ii(J3'''-ncttll'l't'Ejti}ll

i-,J-. c,.r.r--.i !:, *ii,. i-i->i Gi i"(Jl o'u ,rle 4tll "-A 'a<''lt F+ 6'lJltel-,q$l -'^rll teri: 'o-,/nl

''liJb &ilill aXLi" {.-i ai*Lll fill .,.L ar.,ctUt ob-" [*,-J!'"t-',

i-S-- tLl tts--'": f{jl ,ir':&.lli nl.,.P ,r"r ' "i'.*;Jl aj r'--!Jlr {'+-,tl i

sJl I ...L1 ,r.,.r-. \tlv i;J YoY,oc.Jl C+ 1t-i s'r-"o,'"'-'tll ;L ''itj-1i-11

#l r& \ \14 iiJ YY t t'.';t ta! c'.r-3- ; til'r:'Nl tr+i'll i.S=- Jl c,l''-- t

a.iJYAoYf-r.r^-..,JlCl.t!.t+'ral>Jlq'e.r'tc;'r-;l3Jl':!'*Jl--'L-r''

lJ! trr,,-., f<Jl *ff Jl t++clU J.l. f 'Js?l i'ctLll3'rl ' 1l fg:jtll tlto

i! .{!J ir,-i.tl ;,l.lnJl b.rSr.iilJl 'rl'r,!-l 69c'r,r-e <is L; '.u t* Jn'Jl

.d;$i 95. Ji--,J {.rt+ L- glc ':.,2 f'r gtl'rJt l'ra ji;i #Jl ;l

6^ t.l i.rlll ; Jsll ;,Fl u-i rJl 1j dli ' ql- ,r.,ll l'b.".1! 'r^,r

re-.r I e :t 6jl J - tl 6l'cl .,,-' ..,,-sJl e"-+* Jl i''+* !' t'11 (J,l4 u'L'iLJl iI,jG

g.+: .rl ..,*.rJl -rr- ! <.,1 .,lc J+ - (Eilr-lL {Lerl L- "'Xb "tstinilllll

Jr .K': 'l ,r" L '.ill l ,,r.r! c,bl-'i3-y dtJiJ"JJl r-l'-1 ,*'r''t3 ;,1 , - ll csi'c'r cI-'

e;r-"Jl ir J! "fdl 't-?J t- Ii!-i 'JJl "t''-i ;o i'r-}'- t+l! iil J ^ rl irt ^ ^

1... ii! tj.isl r, \v a.Ji

i33:, ,*"---i ajl,, - . i - t. ..'r r+ di J!3 .-{jjti- p .tJ:..| elp +- .FJt J..-C

.t;s- .rJc. E;lj ^ lL ,tcJYl l.s;. . e+::--: Ly jj,tll 4l LrJrj .Jl ql - _ tl ;,. o.

6sr J-? CiJ rj 6jlt ^ ll ,r.lc

"13.r-Jl ;$ d L. clJi JlS ,J'sJl J,-q L.rrJl eJJli ll lin.,.e - 6J l ,-!-l asLe.r, .r.r irll ;L(3 ,cll.t.rt5 Ll .JJl J,,-L .slcJl

,-l++-,,.j.,.tL.. r<;'s.rJl c;L(3 . ta-:s a ,_4..,- ,r.,1- .!= 15l Ji inSlll 15.JL-c'J !+ _

ill,itl 15JLcJl .Jr+ r. "l: .-:G-xJl aj.r L_p,.-.31 ,f * E.r_2l3Jl c,l ir. ^.rr;

| -..L1 ;r. \ttv ir-J yoy aurcJl oG iucrtl,l iJ6F f, &J ,.rJl J-.C

'|,--ir ,;- L-5-,-+slelll a.,rJ.c,;.5l3Jl c,)l_-.-.Jl .:.t-."-a F.sll .:.1j

c,ri'; rs:,cJl oi-o c;LS li! Ajl+J! +ilc;l t-.r i .., {jL ",j. J+ l-d.r{yl A:"U.ll

6...;5.r.,-r.s tr<...":;^-r.tul Jl GIJ?I 6j c:pEll 6iS l;!.pa_.el irj.ttrJl +

t^, o.*i*iu 6LJl .JL- f+-i+ \1tlnlyA i.-{- "t'._!lrn*yt aX-t Lrifl.t q-.;.6,1 f3 .iJl .:Xi;! ,-+ C !.i a,,Lu f.,rt ;t3 .g,l ,...:.... iy o.r.,-i

.<,aii +i|r,-o dt* rJ,-+ 'L.r"r." irsJ n Ell 4:ilL- ;,.c ':rL; cu