رفض الطعن في حكم بأحقية عامل في صرف معاش العجز الكامل: قانون التأمين لم يفرق في استحقاق معاشي العجز "الكامل" و"الجزئي المستديم" إلا في مسألة واحدة

lr r r {lg1 d* SJ ar. 1 ards

i.rLJl Lpr.3 ixsfl d-i:J.,.1L col+ll c).* /rt .+r...11 .:..,11 i-tj..r,.,

,6rrJl 6*- .iXsll d-,:- J,r:'jtl ,r.il-. e.t- ,dl +. Jt S /U)t.1.1 ...t.1

''rli '.++j .'^- I

( ,t11 )

ajL:6rl 1f aisJ 01 6 flIJ U.rLtl

.<ur!Jl rtrt.o, r,all ( I )

,,, I *rtll faJl ,e,r-- 9_)E "* i.,_! L.J" L]jj, c+i!l ,-q,J}y c,,Ljl JLr_,-

.e'Lily YoY .Y\Y ;[oL!l

.ngrLll elt,.,,.lr U;il .(f.sJl ti+*l!:l 1s.r. (Y)

.xi.Lal.sL,+ *-Xl .alJ tal.r-t LLi< .ilii* c,Ltc,r.Jc. f<.JI LE!

an'

.(j.r.rJl L,.iL6D n6Lr-. .a-rr,tl3-l crLi:p'rj (l,)

J*lsll '-*ll en !," ,.ij-,i . \lvo iiJ vt Jrl\A t .:-Jt oit-"Jr;-:...1

;.".i ,-ha .l3,..3 pJ. ; i1pll ill-.Jl ,r.i eJ,.ill d"j-h.*l l^Jr )l f.Ji...'.| ujlij j+nb

.J[",1] -..-L- 6J oiL .r.j*X

.:1,-il_/l

",iG & yoy .y\r c1.-t.rLJl t':lr,;il| i,J.ti a,tll Jt .i ^ -\.!i Jr'.].tl SJI rr,. ^ e,-.rb; J-?t +..- lrr L.2 ag-

alir,.,." c,t-li,J + ii-il lj! a<,tt "i - r; l a"<-_" ,1. .. (J-i _ rJi. _y.e* ,1";,_"1 l-al.rL *l".Jl J!.i dlJ i.il,S l-al.s! c;t(j

Jrl ^ll (J.l ^::Yl q*L:ll .;L3;r. Y/\1 , \A;,.,:.rlJl ,rr "Jl J,s -f

Y. . . :l- arl- 9: sla I i.rJs

iiJ tY.r \1VV inJ Yo ,sJr il':'Ulq +l:'r': ''-.s \1Vo ii-J V1 f-!J &"1il1?

\A r.rtll ;* iltll EJ3.i'! t1'+:.*ff cJ-t-r'^ rili^r"'l d,fr+ d g:":Jl .)1 \vr'

..r-a +.-/i-l L^$ !l - ''r ' "r 1 ;J+! }-!l ..*''r J'tlll :+.t11 g1-, ;5'rll a-aJLJl

;l ,rf" pl .-,.-1,- 15J {i$ i,.dJ Fl J* ''s-. r lJ' r.,}i e." ;';^-- Xl iltJl

6- otSllt r,l;y'r-:Jl r-.rr .r'.>1"l, l,1r(-;:i rlr'=''.r:J' *' '31,,5-(--

arS-all

-,.l.3ll JLi: '.tl rrJl .)lJ 19ilt -"rill 6L--3.!l3eX! ,rl" 6)rtJ.ll 'r'-'

' il31 J!'s''.3 ir-il3ll3

- Jlrfll JiL-r e-i-i i15''ll! #Jl ee calU "L - iL3Jl ;! i'''"-- 'l

Lr,i rr-,& \ tAV i.iJ \ o o I + 6J,-Jl llil .bYl oJ"'-' ito:lll ;i '" .'},.-.-j]

U.r;;g,!fb - +!-i-Xl r,,!."i:! A'-- 3lll a:*'dl - ibtUl ,rJ' 1$ls'-!l ''1"*r-

, i-r. rrLcl .,a d-.i-=- L i(-JI :JLr i',-i-lr,r"'--Jl u-Lill LLJI ;:idl - +ul

llj. ;s <,t olecJ 'uto* Ju, , \1 V/A/\Y ,rr +lQ! g,;uE o" 4l Li=iJl u:tul

.t),Lr i-i,,rr J.L" 4+"i \1Y1/\\/\ &' I'i* +t-'r+Xl oL*''r:ll '"<' 6J 4-'1c

er Qr:.-.. fr-t< 1:'+. oiir -u,'1 .r'ul ':,:+-*""rill r.r3 \\At/Y/A e*.lu.,'r

JlEr \lAt/Y/\ i.,' 6l j't 'l ilJiJl 'rKll '=ll oiL$ t-,'J 'r-L-Xt ll-a slc

\1AV/ /\Y ,' l]L::'l t!J"'- ilJl iicttll ii'-rll c''G 'ris o::uil ' iJ ' -J

fi-r s.rl-pll etr-ilJ lt,r^ ff.-S 1:'., J+,iI {.:,1'-l ,Fl 4G- }! ULJI ;1 c''rc'r''

..!-s fs CILJ! JjL-r e+'-+ JLjn:--l ,-d (1nj-,t'--'tJ \14' iiJ Y1l

;.!Jl r,ltS ib, \ 1 V/ /\ Y eJq i:tu dr+ -i+r,rJ! q;lll irt e'r'll

ai* r.,. fl.n*..'K -+. olf- ;1 \\M/\/A &::.,t+ c'-.'r" $ -i"''- A A+J"ll

i;+- .:'U! -'+.:,i., ul:i- I ( ]l' u;-!'ilr \lAY/A/A Jl I ( r*,b e-' -8 6! ,x-,;i

ijGull ii,.dl 6.! c.,Le-lLtl rF--i irJ .;Kl qll JL'ill 6JliJl ,l,alJ r';tr-'y-g

Y. .. ;Ua aiJ" JJr, I iarr

.,.r|:ill -i:i {+lL rsJeJI tGl ri! .of,Ull . iiJ Jl_r^j-b 4JI; L;iJ,Jl :.t:r1 ,3

, i: ^ 6.rGl .,-i &?t aG a,r,,!Il !:i.-L L.(_ll ._.. . i tlAA/\y/yA g;tns

#Jl lJi a.,.c,tUl c,ii'G-l . \1AV/A/\ \ .,i <-iL+! g::rE; ,1(J .F=Jt dtr"\\\Y/o/A trLir.r,JYV iiJ Vy fiJ.-iU:i-yL -i,*r- ,s+ ,_itr...,:...1 i.S;6J

LAill ;",J"\ l<JI 116 sj i.ietul .:.i,J..-ilij_Jl #Jl J*in L-(Jl .-.^<_

I s : i .3+l +<L tl-$!l L:*.r,i3 .,;:ul ,rr s--Jl r.r; . ..., &'$ 6J; ,s.etll y.r3

u-i Lx-l'l ,Jc;.tll ,-'-:- jb .i(Jl Fin L.-;JI .,jr iJl u:i-l+ 6Lll

t{i'rJ tt*Jl c,.!l k;- I 6}.i] a_j+ c,.ur i::*L iiri

3o a,rtll .,.! GJI l.J-. .j &?l o.r.' ul-l.t.l ..1." 6+l 6sJI ,.r.+.,r1 ..:-.r

.{._iJ (iti i,rri,fl Lre qi* ct .:-.il .r,., $l ;eL.I ,;l

u,,.:.rlJl I : i., u-iJl i,.,J+ ,:-ttl JL.j- .r! cllj .r..r_ .ri erJl .rl .: _,r

fJl -rr.r. g,Jti c'" J..-Xl \.,-- l+ 6,r: irF- c,trllrll uJjG; yoy ,ytfri arctul r,i_L<J \1tf/o/ r.,/,r,. .r! arr,.u,r!11 _gl 6L< .ib ,!-i ir.,!11

arJl frJl G-, cl \\\Y/y/y d. ;iJt a-S-_. ..tjs fLr;,Uf iip_.- ;,c.rsi

63;t-i *n-aff Jl .+tl .,-a fr:.-!l $ irE J.L!f ;!-i .++_.,.Lutf l faJl JrJJa .,-

.u.L-l Jer *f" 6".rtt ,r.._a_,

.i.K-iJl ccr . i.rJ ,-.fun_,| i,,!ll ;l ..:-,

a, ; i.rLll #l ,J- irctJ.ll I ^ 6:. ur.,j i{11* rl" fi}il ,.el.ll J! e,__- J

,.:li1-'rll >-rr rG.r- Jgyt ;JUl Jl l'[rr c!;;! crsr .irrliJl &:tj (J3 iLr ll

qj -.3lJ,t'rl #,.i,_E- - i:.,-Jl cr-!,"':ll ,r ,.:.y;.t _;_,_Ll \1A. tj_J ylt fiJ

.!ll3?l GJc U:i,* iJ 5)teJl .JjL-: C+.+ c,r-iij-l J-i &J<r;i.J-t<l .,+nl pS.-

illJl ,4...r 13 \\AL/y /L,r_i.;rt .^U LLJI ;_,_^Ul iiJfl,lri;l .r. p..!tr

;,.,-'!l ,JLJl . Lrlb,,*"i1l L<J,JI . iJLtL .11^i, L6:L o.r.;,.1-J.11 .,+,J i.,-1*.Ll

{.,i Yl J"F;l ii- in itLJl ,lb L<Fl lj-i L.J,'..,-r g)l_;,lL ctj+Jr* 6-

Jl*i,Il GJljdJl JlJnl fK.-y i-iltilt &L< i,$.,.4a:l+. t!L=-,t,..r.; Jl .e.._t

Y. . . &r aJ- J-r oj I a"'ls

n++Ulf ,UJ L;S./l ;;l't)l .+ I6ifl iJL' "'':'c i'cttll c.,'rLei ql"'U''r'qll

L4!-'ic.,-,.r-..-l f,.r.J.,r-,i+;.1c L^rl.j-cl ;l \1AV/ /\Y13jc'tjrl '{Fl

oA r.rgt eilS UJ.aJitiJl plS.-13.!q1..5o3 ' &t<tl -'+'ll uitl4" ir - -itili

6 iJ-,r+ll u..-ill iJtc! .,lt l.:i-{X oitei 'r3 \1vo ii"J v1 fJ JL'rtall qt"

i)lll DLi a;-" .-E ir u i+Jl c'.J+ e.-eE,r'*11 i.rJl J)l-iJ'-(ii ai-'"

L- .l:$ i;fi ;r. c,l-;- y..11 .ta-,l .u-, i+Jl ..;sJii E'rbl ':uL^o 'iJEJl c'l3n'"

\\At/\/A 3ac,!31- i-,.,pXl ;r-"...,l " ^l'l--1--1 ir"',g.ltl g;L:Jl ;l oL;:n'

irtc! ;!-a i.r.-l',rJ(Jr 5!l ;uru at -*'''"-J"ll ,rJc o'r''- *'rJ'rl ';>c g-eL:

:+. J! rl.rilt Jl,J,n \1AV/ /\Y 9-;[i c'"Ll .,rll +J"ll i++ll '-J" dL.r;r'

antlJl oA;.r[l ,rs Ql. c,-,r-]Jl ol3i- y.,1'!! ,l '' -'11 gl,s f., .rillfr;il

rl,i ii.,till i+ ,ll ilL- e-. rl ni+ ,!xl lJ.6 d.'i &r.'!rl r<Jl '-lJL: ib ';Sill

+!c \1AY/A/A Jl 61 ii,t- -.{*ii ir- Jl \\iL/\/L,r].,pLJl "'-'+ 'rill

i;Lel ;l ilel^1 J-t<ll -+rlf .ib i-r ' ^ EJtcl .5-i 6r; iil'rtll qn'-i dli 15lc

Li 'f-l:"'* a-,(1 +:!-! .:--ll ''u Jl g-,-.,b .r" c,l.li- 5:rl 'l ':t"l .r'l l:-'r cJ'!l

.+,i!l ..,.ar'r ' ".,

;1 i.XJl o,b 'Li-l cr":*It r* ol ,:tli '&+- ,+ "-Jl tir ;! '+-'s

,-+ r-Jl ;F ,tlJ !:fS Lal.r--! c,rLS3 ila: '- ' c'LLcr,Jc fi-!i lil f<Jl

q-ill uriG;. \A;,rl1l .,3 'Jl 6LS3 .ellj;LS U Ai:' J:- "'s! Lal'rL

Yo .,.^ir,:*-,JiLiJL 4r,: "'-,.s - \tvo iiJ v1 fJr nliGlli;'rLJl ,rcl"-:''-Jl

- \ ,i-,i- il eYLJI ; oiLJt J'-j-"t,, al .rlt - \14' iiJ tY r \1w iiJ

l+Jt rl .&lsl i+Jl rl ,EGrJ ql" "'.rft LJ:'l {iil -Y """-Y ""'

E..r-. c-.15 fal ,.ffi, Jt^,lt i'^ t''- 19J d r'il j-c 'l'i"-. ., f'E c13 'r'- f"rf-Jl

JlJi t-{+<-.in Jr,-t {=J,r".,,1-.,+.r-i J* tr-. r,'sc ;'!'3 U-'Gll ;4sl''il

;.Ft-Il Jl-'^ t ,! tJ't'iJJ ""i'' :iIl 'lrJl g. l!L$!L ':'[v'ull r'u ee

-,{-.i1 iJ)b gc.jiil rt*ill ,,-i cJli.-il a'r- <!e,..pj'"X "tFi 61 (t-r) +lL'Jt

.,3J, dji ,Jc irlill c,li,r* Y/\1 ;rtll .rj; ( ' ' ' ' irt!:- J+-xi a:- ri aI-:-

l'..4i41J+dcta*l5

L....Jll u.l-l ,J" "pt_.U 6r..e sl ,Jl sl ;.J orL.l.l . iJ . :Jt c,yl-;u;;.;.-- '!l tiJl J)i c,tSlJj-iyl k_L_l .,1 .-:rl .pl .1.9,1i,U sU_Fill

d i_-,-tl ,rJc J.u eJJj..p rJ: ;! q-.Ltll ; ellJi,i)l E.u 3l ;r,..iJl .,i ,illj.,-iY

{"ilj..l l^jiYl f..lj,Jl ,Jjj+Jl l+.rJl ip.;J.L(l l+rll ,JtlroGt:_.r...1 ('iSr+

+.J"*ll ,,.-L-15J qt ..,.!"tL'nl J^".,s-..r l& c.u ji *. i-11,=Xl ilL.ll .,.i

;LlslL c.,la-iJl >_p.r. _.r1, l+lSdi -r.r,_ .,Jl irJll ,.r. rl-r+ eUj Cu<l;i

!J=L *t.:; t6l Ji {-i iu..ttl #.Jl ;ls3 ,p$sL ;lS U .a.,-jJl .l.rrrJl e-l*:,. ilii-*;.r9. c,LG.r ..lc,J.lSll :+nl ,-,rt -, iy e.rtcl ,r.i o,_: ar,rtLt(il: ^: ---l dl- rl-.,g sl.l,<ll ,=ll {lL.-,r.i {rt lrll 6t; ^.r ...1 ut <sr* 3>*iJl ;i,

\1Vo a;-J V1 fiJ &ilnll ; \A 6.rul (J_i e-ji fJJjJl (,-!j+ll j+Jl ilL- jl

o,r.,a -ini:tJl 6l:^'i...1 ; ilt r...tl ai*ll d.rL-.r!_t d.r.,r . . . .. . ,jl +:+-il ,J+:.r. -. ._.,1 L.,Sji cc.r,c.r. La',l_.li-|, a1.rl .,=lt ilL-_.-uJi ,r_.., ril - -lr

ilE &i t< f-"1.ri* 'g; 'l;* S* ctG.il e,.,i jl dL- J+ .,j J-l &i<ll

,iiJl t{?14q.{Jt JL,iliJL.ll ,-.rlLdn;,i. .:lrh,.ll .-.,.-26J';_iJL^r_,d.lLill

;t-i .at e rr,:J.11 i(JI ,t .:: JrJ Lar=3 L_iL( LLc.rjl o.i-o c-,:tS .ib _JlrJ,rL

.et J$ .r.€ - tp cs'r-rlt +--., ;S !l - , <>,1 Ltc.r iJl .,l 4.*i,,;

.n-t!l ,-r:iJ A+ lrii U <il ...J-J