نقض حكم بتعويض مشتري أرض من مالكها على الشيوع: لا مانع أن يبيع المالك على الشيوع ملكه محددًا مفرزًا.. وليس لشريك المالك ادعاء استحقاقه في المبيع إلا بعد القسمة ووقوع المبيع في نصيبه

l''' i-l,gr 4j"JJ t,o YA a/r'!t>

;.rLJl L3;ca ax-l| er'.,5- r'.'.,li qlJ'.35'' '"=i /)t ta 'tl +Jl i*"I-i'l,

;,*=r' d- -,,i[,"F'-''-'-rll'r-'c''t-,Jl*'gJl.-'' /' t'ir "'t l

' ;'Lrl '1"3eJ1'+l'l-il

( t'to;

Ait,'atl 1 a-L.J Yl'o iiJ irlall

'(CLJI aL';' &+ (\)

,Jc, 6r,j-.! u-rdll pll ;{;1 'ltF 'tJl ;U-:-l g'Ut ;l^;4-:;

C ;r^rrf ;1 L:G! ;L'Jl *. . 'r+ o:b o;*::It g'*r eJ et'll '';1 4;r'i d .!-

.;& t1\1 .rr.

"Jr.

^:ll Ji JI,YI (,n LF 'rl tgFl ;13 "l3c'r "s ,.9- '.Jc (A

uylaJr uyLr .<is'rJl ;)Lbrr <l$-l.al J-rj t-o :tlrJrfJl ':'J-Jl'fs.s. (t-f )

. a+,..,0' e-S:-'' e-' *dJa# | gti'rl I D u;J€ J' ( I lSiJ I

.6L;ji..t4itJlr<Jl-1.-"1,rtri-ic<-rj'r+gG'rcr-'r<JlJLul(Y)

#t ;:t-lr

r.-,-i.r 6Jl elill ":ll .11 ;i1 ,'ctLJl tlrl i-rL' &?l o'r*! .-g"tll 6'.''r (Y)

,-r;.11 @,.Jt .l r, - rr'r E.rJ i'SJIr ,r+ 3slr ,J" "jKJ'i 'sl i3EJl ta'r-;;,'ul

{i,--i }i- Xl eL-;;rctLll ;d3r+rl ;rill g* ';J la:=sL r-a=5i ry'r-' o'r'''' t+i"Gl

i.," J+,JeXl o.r-;.rr'r!^ll l''L u .rL q+':"r'ir,-';$ 6* ./ L:*dl "1" tllE

. r.,-! 6.1 #Jl JGi! cs3j- LEi 6r'' dJi L!"K t" cl! Jl 6Jl ''Fl t+';

i:+n r]. i:41,-.;s,fb g1* l-p*ir- I'r'r'-' <SL es+'lll .,J' ':llut C- (t)

ll Ly:Jl ,1" .l'-:,.' ;S 'r3'- ;;--'X t'J "':.,l es:':ll 'Jc Ll'r/j'il iil+! Jl {''*$l

Losrr i-*!Jl ,+ Yl e+l ;,.rti-j-"Jl u'+ 'll - Lr:ill ';" cl':,5 "' <L ..,-ll-

.6Ji,-i,-X iul +i'-' i J r.6 i'.*'4' (J.i tJl

l. , . an! 4sJ9 A. y a4rrs

.,.i l<Ji-rill 6-;y+, <:i + .-,jJt ailall .r" !i\ rrU d u,-Jl _\

,.13.r,,j+Jl laa,rlc +,- -lt . ^.: ri 41,_,,J*+yJ tJl c.r_=sas, .-;-l :rl.rclt^.,tIr.rJl ,,i, (jr'4JL iul A:i $;ts ,:i. ..jt . . ; f^;,r.r.,- ,:xj .,-a ,.L+ Jl

-L "& C.++Vl ,;i 6:Ul .y+ d l-.:tlj JS .Jl,-i. +<.L_ .-l1.rl otr..r3 p.:)llli.tti Y tgri-:t| J:.-.-: ar^ 6*Il .91r_.r..,y gul ;L.;6l ,.rl. J+ _"13o"; g-e+i+;lltr {-;.ri .,-c .}- ,L *Jl * 3,a, oJ.,;r_r:t.t ;ts ljl xlJl;^ :..r1l 41".' -..i+1 dl i,--lJl c,L,:.J,,JL {,lc 6J:-irll ls=. -1 6_sa.;t $tJl

'rl _rlroYl L/ Lr.; $ 6Jj.ji!l ,is ol.*";,-;'.=.,L;E l,ir-.f l "1i c*,.,.,6q

.{tu Cl.^:ll

1G:;.-,.r<Jl Jual .rl - i-s-_ll oj.o ,La! ! cr_,: L uJcJ _ JJill _y;i.,::!l (J-i Gj*s L_.,re+ lGJt l.rn ots tjl #Jt d.ti !L,..rJi t-Jl o,.!lt^r q-ilJl iaJl .,rr...i __i trr--! Jl-iill dtj "+_j jt ix-lt t-{:Jl -.s.:l ,r+ll

"ii ,sl Jan ;i ls rr. 6K 1G.r a.-S-_U .,L Crf ljl <.l ,jtt.] 6rj.3 .<r)L ,r_:lili*riJq L"-n" <:L L li, _:- err,5.r.,,ri:6i teLl r.r^ als J.Li GU,cJl j,'t ,,-U r*^<- nt< &i: C,rj,l,G t{-L;i./ "ji .,L. ;::tt,.ai J! .-._ . ^

QU;c'fUf + LFGi l3'tt o,.:;r,LU ;i ('J'.J, (J.i itlil cll< .]t _y

"stLJl

ia_,i*i - i-El tiG ,r.rL.ll u_!; dJ d** 6.ill tl.ll *:Jl JJJ ,lq {.L.1!oo o

,..oJ 1giJ""JL ql l( . 'J"n Crrl 1.6.,- (._,lL-: Jjj ,J. _ lSXl j CL<.j*i .s.r3i=LJ le :a<t^ l+*a c,c;lj Li r. - t{:-Gl uJl a,il.r:,-yl --i rl,& \11f ai.J;t53. \11\/\ ./" dt C+ll "_i-:,_.r.i iFtLjt ; +l 1!fl ,.r.iJ, ;r, "*.,EJl-- i.it ... " &' 6,.. ,.L.,!ll J! l.*tl "rr;i3.rsUli rl ,:Jl dllj LF q:Jlr-,-i 6""tul ;l ,:gll >:n: ..r- c+ $J .iJ+l cF,= ty u-yy t-iJ$ ;.uir6J

1Li <.c.tr;,r_!.r 6J,.Jl .,_i.r,.rll ,*rill tL.l ,,t .,^, S *i?l ;lS3 !y r.A t{;L ;13 q5,^,; ljri. Lri e._, Dl tr+.j,ll ,r_1" cIJLS +i- r- O, gr_rr, a.a--c,lJE" iS_r J-ts,i.j.i! Ji 6.111 (J.c..,*Ll| 4+J_-j U.c, Jn glxl o , . . .r.rL^ll a.cL

4-:. J J*+i - ixJl 4Jl -.lr^i J - ELa.Jl |,ra .,L:: "* OL(: .ijJ_ii ij$ tl,: crJ,Jl :- : . gYl,r.c;: .ri fu till La.r.; a"ort^lj j.r+r y €l ol Jj., ;f :1,s".f f ]' oejf

I. '. ti4 4s" JJ i. Y^ a4l5

t"i.lh L. gL -L!.rclul d'b l0 . iJ-'i.,; J- .,1" .-. :t t<,!j JbtJ e+lll .,s

;. I E \ E.rtll nF EJ.a_ 'rl EJ"iilt? )L"c ;illll . ;r,,ll Jr ^ .:t d.lj-:Jl 4rc ,,tirj

c... irl Ji t+"tr;S!l ;L.c_ 1 a*t,13-,-- tj d t+'rr ,..r .^. ;J.l arl3ll

.;bll .G,.L.,L"11 td,. J.,-ul ,;Jr;Jt as;g. a=Uq Ls*-,r"i

iul g.'t L i;,.r"il {-il - i.(51l 6;i el.:t ! cs}.- L,rL., - _,rdl -t

.-,lh,! oja q.sill iJL;'13'tr,t ir,^.<L6,-Alte-ll ,rj" LcU;S 61,

! 4.K lia;l Y! asgtt ,r1"..':, u,tl arl .!3! i*-nJl i11::,.,.L inl,* JI i]$r*

i.,th.31 1.ry:U ..f.'L<.,.;;tSi ,lr,* - J.,-:-, J u/:l l;!-i ;tltr e+lt J_t-

r+i.r.r i*iJl ,,i Y! e+l d Jl: -.l@Yl rf+Jl - tri*Jl .J" et,:,r:;; e<L

(-'i Lr;rll idt-. i.ri,ill ib .6Ji.ill eX.ll itill :+.-i d ! Ji 4*..r Lj C.,Jl

j,i-.i ;l l+il .j. -. j i,,iir ..- :.ll rJ. d.+_;rn h .srrj+t 1U.rJl los,[l;

,',-+rl"l.t c,s..rl .,ll A--=l ... l,l Li+J ,,;J,.ll ;L*-.; ;,cttll ,rl" L.:_r-rll -,=. . +.

i.-.:rlt ii..l Jb'rl or;;r,,L.X +cL 6Jl J$Jl AA; L+l l(.rxt- i-nHl La-G

#.Jl ;!-t a,z:t,1 ;,clJ.Jl 1l-!r c,:+ 6r+.,,r I a.rllu _.4!l L{+l u€li,}l

.:,-.*"iJl ,r-i JJ,i rLi: Ji iJq a.ti JJTLII

A.-.as{l

:r_rl!l ,l .;r ...(1 a.Jl o)j 6.111 lJ-i:ll g L-*3 ..9l,3'Jl ,s.L g)ltyl ,rl

. il3l Jl .u,.3 iril_.;Jl3

.i.,K.:Jl <-cl .:,rl;$.-l J,tI Jt .-,J-

- ;lrjYl ,:L-3 +14;s-rl.ll *-.tl ;,1* L,L - il.-3lt ;! E+..-,r

6r"cJl &Xl a, . ' JJ,ttlJ ,rsttJl .rJe c,-ttl i,itll L.G ;ryllt ;1 d J.-.=ll

,.rq q;t . ":. L"-{-lji.! SJI :.tl.i i:,jlJ:_,'rl l:- i;.r_. \t1r ;i...1 ooo aiJ

u;Ji i,L!.'l !i^i L4.l .:lli;+.ri cJ$J . ilI-JlJ l-{-r.,-} oo. 6t+- t<.J t .l+

,.r,Ul3 cFl,tll C;s ,ris i+,,1L ii.,ll ty.F\, ,r" t.J+.i !\ d.'\ l(i^ | ...^

Y... ald d!_ J9J.l A a4l5

J& i-1,*ll oia g..r rlrrr ib \11. ltc .1r-..-,-Xl ,jJ-l+ l-(+ Jl JrXl oG

\A1 1rJ GUEJI JbXl .,.' ar.'!ll fGl L-( .at+Jl ijJL- t+t :'1L. 6FJl ;,'L3l

i1,[; C.- d.5.rj1 ;L #Jl i.tU;"t'ttt ,;i 4i:lJ+l ;---1 .rrr" \110 a'iJ

Ltr \1\\/\ ./" C ity,rirc eii J-3. e,=. r ., {r! tdl*; Jt3r '{++ 'jtli -*i!c

d +r f, riJl l+ i.rsa.* i:,Jl tY d-YY lt: - L- --;Jl i'ti q' qF-l: AptUl ql

L."ll.,

"," l+. ilr ll 4ri:iJ *.,a: c-; t!-q eJl 1i.6./ ar"(Lll u-.: t-";l

;l "r.;l L".#!l iirJL- cq;'-cJl q c,.Lni a!|.r.......... ..-. . /f-*>ll

a,cllJl .,L *tl t"<+ rs.-. Jt d o- ib 4i Jltll ilJl lrC C-,+ k-- Cr ' iU

,:,-;^i o,.,>il 1.l3 sl .l-,..r.rJ3Xl 1gi,cJl ., bi+ i-SJl ;'t.$ cgl'cJl tGl &i

\tto/\ \/Y\ e-rl-,: - : i: ,..-ts f- L--$:i Jr-:i! tL:. i/.J '*-,-.r'"Jl f'+

,-,cttll 1l;J! \1to iLJ \Al f5 rs;*;.ll ss.r \11f ii-ol oo o pr cutJt .r'"1

i<.Jl l.ia ;stUl ..ir:ii*l .4.,r-- -ilj ,,j* +L; ei+..13?l ol;,'r"'t^11 ,5;j1 ;L

,Jv. iiJ \.M f.) .-iLi:i,YL - CLar'- L-x,"L - trr-i .-ilili-l i.(*" tt'i

.q,-t! \11A/1/\ o tJ-rb.,;,;3 6,,J$ t$;1 .r-,.3 .s:cJl ; 1ro+ i-<--fl ;'s

c,rl ;;5i* !$l r...r;3 ,-"inill i,J,ti f-Jl l.r! # i.,"llll a+ ..-ii'LL-Jl f<Jl

i-iJj Lr-i, ^<^ 1.1 oia ,r.L ,..1.,..1".11 ,;:- ilu .{+ nJ,!l f<Jt Fijf 6'l!l t.41-i

't{:'rJ q$l -'utlt Q;- : Ar["] i4ll oJJs 8j}ii

&r,rLill . -qi+l"i j it^:-ll a, a irrlll #l ,+;rctul .Li b r! 5:-..r

.!= r.;ts u di! &+ ulli;l-l* ,r"r .Llirjt 'i- Dti)lr yr+*ill ,r3 rr-,^illJ

t"-, .5Ji.iJl o,$isl L .-i)E.rb d:-+ t-j" j- ,,Jc 1;! C ;gll ,l '-'r:: pi glll

(,.i .-$xl -,i+ll fL.i ei,.""i J!.! ;l ^. : lL iql "rl" L,r"-. -Jl -.,;- ltJ a-,- ;,-1 X

.l.3 ljrl:ll ta.r-;;,--Lll o..:*..r 6-::-" ;1 f :;;Il A"<---" tL^l <-cLi.r ,r-ir a5-e'"s11

,'".,!.ll lrL t iL llir" lJJi d++,--1 *Js .,i eJ:..,1 t3*; JL A$1 a:)i.iL;

,;1 p".:r aJ. o+ e-J a," 4.(- riJ {..,. J31 sl. ,-.c>lJl 4-s; .l3r-5' ,/ &11 or'-

; s'13ll {5f ,}e 4i.-, -...3 cl !l lta.rll lin J[ 6]J-3l .rr.rGi .G *+ll

*il.r cr.ei .Fb-i ,JJ C- -Jl 6Jill &t< 1,ry fs CJI r$ll di tllJl ;d!

rJl ,.'.{-iil L" (,Jc r.}l $ t! ar.rl"Il ,<-Ll ;s ur .dll-J t Lti {.]l L{-- i*,1

I. . . ais .!- JJ u.' I^ l"Js

,, Ld t 6;SL +EJl Lai-;;-LIl r.,''rl .Fl 4'-t*Il '-ri 'r ov-"r-; 'i+ll

1rr.1rr, 6r; &r.,L^[ 6' e$Il rrill aF; Jir: \ttY LJ ooo f-r rsr'Jl

LAJ; &r4J,-lj c,-i.r 6Jl il+la "il" g.e. -.,11 .s" F- 1l i-n"'- L o'L;! cllJ ''Jc

,l'u; ir 633+ lLi'r <.i y 1'r'rJl tcGJ..r-'r-: ':1 ;l d ta-;'; dJ +t-:il' - ; :,-. i,,,1 te l*" ;& 4r!i 6r'cJt .,i 61;Jl a--' 3 <-, ;11 ;1 o;;

,1" ,3rll ,r9l-.ll ,-r' { l \ i'rLl! ss trJ! ;1 rlli "s'r- sJl 116 ;! er'=r

Jl dj--, u-,.i-. -)tl i:.il ;*"-^ +^'r irr 'l JJ ;L^Jl ti 6Jj-jJtl .!=:-,1i-" <'',1

Ji,ltS ,r:." ..,.il ' ' ; f<.a '1jt'- tllj ,r'a.;,.tsi;1 ;l 'tiJ! l'ra t'Jc <r-" tJ' ' ^'r

C u,:il: Js.J,+ + d.=- ut-l ...11 olcr3 f')lrl -'irtl .,r crr.J! illll rL:l

;r:-.r.

..1

6.,U1 ;r ^ . : 6'! .rlr J+ -ol*a ; F ,1" "* d "+'-. Vt Jl iqll ti+

,1" ,+l .r^ +^s srJJl .rFl ;15 l;l Xl 'L'-i'+ i (J;J:.jJl a .:'': t" 6*Jl

c,r- ^.1J.:ll,4tlc G}.ill Lr-. J ej+;i 6-,$1 6r+ gJUtU.s Crlj,," t9=

ol3c.r,rs,i= rL;$ dgiFf ;1 qq ''q JL!''-r-Xl oL; '"i!' 'i 4l a'-=lJl

! csJ+ L ,rbu - r:;ff .;. .16l e 4r ' ^'rll ,i -rl:'!t .r' LJ; $ tr;':rll ;i3

;)lL {+Ic *.-rt: fJl olsl 1Gr ,;}^ I i<Jl Jtl;! ;1 - i-.<Jl oia "L'a-3

tt axJl laal! -.e..rl ,Jt a---iJl .,r lr.r-'t L..ll-* Etl'rll li'a;L< lit #Jt

eltj 6ri.3 ,4rlll", ,.';r-i L"i oi-'tJl #Jl -'L-i d l$'-! JLaiXl cllj t'-:

'L,:; ;tS ;!.lr aes,cJl ,r, l;;l "/ JLJ ;1 la-lc ;L< 1Gl L'(Jl .slc Crt li! ql!

.i,ir!{,6.!iJl-'^L'ilL'1""i'{:LLlil.j's+i1.:s6l'.;$iJiklllli

GJ,.JI (J.i ilrll ;15 l-I3 .t.r'-ti rt <^ jt( }-rl: d "''F t*-'u: ; '}l '1"

,l 4.,6rli el+I! oil! ,ri rq +'l-![ uU '.,stLll 'r'L t'6.1!1 ubY! oG;'].Il ;1

,;! ,+ - iSUl d cjl (r'; 'b'b 6etul +:;; - aSlJl La'r-;6''t-X c.,-;'r

a;fs,ff *;f ,r,,r" \11Y aL'''t ooo fr 6J'Jti 4l l( '^rd dJ t{-'' 4JL-i

; +.1 1L$l Jrnl .,-i t\ o'1 a'-LJ I € t J<l^ l-{-'-! ;'c'rl3 L-a'r-o ll r 'L3i .sll

;.uli;I r-3Jl eu3.,. ++ll alss \11\/\ ' /a L;dl6+l 't3- ''''"'3".,;ctul

o;J-i tY o-YY LarJi Eli''J irJs-" i--L'''" &''l o-r; ,;'s"J'fl 'l! l3ct "r-.,l:i3

.r; F- 'i! ;lSs .tY .r' t-+" <-'-'1 ;cttlt ;l +!t 'r*1l., "..;'"'' 'Gj' i-:itl

t. ' ' a;- d+ & Y/l i...ra

<-l-*;61 LJ;etl i"L- 1Li <-c,Li'J,r.ir (sr,cJl (J-..-$rll J{+Jl pLl .,r...-.r

,-[Yl o, ' dr",.]- tl <-L L a.l: q*;,_r. i;.i- lrrt e*,.11 L-c:*r.lt + .UL<

;153 . i:,ril aj)lj dlI cl ,irr- i<i J-tS," +! Ji o,itt ,r *:,J qi_-j a)",J+

;l il cir,aJl ;,sirll c-.3 r+$: - i.-SJl 4Jl -.tL. J _ gG.rll l.u ,,u& ;

G.u JElL.e e{l ; 6r;^ r ..,y1 ,rc,r: ;i i.,:ul r^r; ;.,1.-rf ,r--, y 4jl olrjr.

;l -. ', e-"l;Jl & eli1 l-i

"fL+ U et+ ,:.! rr,tJ.Jl ;b t4-;_)- rr.,=,1".*:l| .-J.^r ;Jt drJlnl ; i!\ E.rlJt ; ar1=ll EJ.i_ittr )Lr;$LUt L;J,rjll

L$s" a=L"IL l(..+^.. .-.. ^i.:-l .! t{j.rr <-ill ;t:-'t' i.*i Jr,.- as d f+"r.r

:t'L;.! ! cqr+ L,..-l.: - -u* sa U,!'fl 6G dr,,L-U L& &-Ul ,;J,,X!i.r..- ^ <.L 6*.;i a.:Jl ,r.f" i<u;S,jl, itill et+ L *.:,-"+J 4.,i _ i-<Jl8il ?.1 rl a-*il| q+x .,Jc {-il,- ri i_ir.!r-.-.rr r! oj_a _r.,,-rt, alL a.tr UF,lr- -;*-:*^I u"+l n,,ti JlJtr e+ Jt__ y 4lS lJ.!;i yl a.*:Jl .r.1c,,r,_*:Jl

Jl:-'t .,Yl .5"+ oi - 3s:lll *J. "I*_r.r,-r. cSL 'tiil. ri ,*ejJl ,L fS,*,; 6tSl.6Ji.iJl ,.:lJJ it+tt ,+.*: ,r.i Y 3a <.,-.a: ; a*fl g.rur i.*"!ll .s yl C$l .,-i;- ,'ll r.:" 4i;:+ L- crJi3.>Jl LL-iJl h! "bL; .p r_+;sll i-<s_. .-.: a:tl Jbd+J,J;J4ll ;l ^.',;.,ctul (JL e,r=. _rJ *.=.*.,-!tu !l La.ir .::,.,,/ +j,,,'url^ll tL 6ill Jr lar.; U t{'r:<t^ aibil UG au,,!ll c,c.rl ,r:Jl i-l ...t1

3G.r c'- ii 6rr+ ip-i d cs;lls,x+:tr Ldt u,^l=.;Jt t++xt i"_.i..6Vr ".-r,:.x t::+:.Jl cr.i L-^i qL:: Ji;r"(:,.a J.rlLl #Jl JFtJi.tttJcttll,-atl 6- cr-* crl ,r.ls.i--t-ll :,t+*l .,"!...- ltL=L-,fr.r:+Jl lr+l 4;_a;

.irLYt