نقض حكم يلزم شركة بدفع دينها لدى بنك: المحكمة التفتت عن دفاع جوهري للطاعنة بشأن تجاوز البنك للحد الأقصى المقرر قانونًا لسعر الفائدة

t ' ' ' t-lg1 d- gl ir 1 a-urti'

i.^<Jl L"tir itj .4-!.ls-,-c. .1.-.r.-a c,r-i-1 .s /tl i; ,t,1 J:*Jl i*E..;,,

st'J-.r 1.l.l ,uc.olr, J.^.tj.,J. .'^- - "L /U)t i.; ".t.\;alJl L3;sa

.GJtL"Lll ,5rJl.r.,c. -l a.(Jl u-,i- J .,lJj

( \rr )

a.t3t, -riJt 1A aisJ AVl p3J 6rlaJl

.lrr Lo :.frJ.riJl .r. Jir) 1.Sr. .tj*igtl i.-osro .<63,-srJl .,3 gGrJlr r.l;Jar ( I )

.<ljg,,al

.gGJl lja r:1 pSJl Jfiil . {,i-aL.tl" "rJLJ r};Jl A.(- f3J u:Jl ati.lll

.'rr,.i

.lb pE .aj.tji .elul ..i" .dJ+ .(6J3Lill Jrsl 6J-iXl r..Jh rllgi (1 - Y)

,2,- J,- .,L ;.Jl 6- .,:lJl JLi6l . l+il i- t. ..1

"" J,-'*t .{iitEJl rtlJ,ill (Y)

ttLilL {itri .i*iLinrl ;JjLiX ('"i?l dl .44i} JjlJl Jyji-l ;l3s pe .5:l . td

.elli ilc ..r:,u Yfva .i;rr^ " 'g111- orlil L + Jl-i':!l .j)lL .ol.r.1*.pLJl

u-.s- Jill .i:.il-6Yl aJiLiu ,r,-i1l ".sll ":'rr" LAjltir...l ,iri- J.,3ll c,$"rJl (v)

t-a,r3.r.-.rr r-il-,ll ,.:lJ,i:ll jJ+i!'jll JjL,ill Jt -"1 J,rsi s.a (,jSJl ,:l:Jl arlo! u-br

1l-, aytilt 1t(l ,;e.r..,rL Li"LJl .r3-i,Jl sJc rl-'.-Xl oir.iL-- .s,l,l-'tl si6 ;a

.gfu. l{ L,u'r. cru3 €.,Js Jl i.iG c,;tS Li- \1vo iiJ \Y.

rs5J,ll .,1r,.t| r,lJbi .EJlJyl ;lLl.-. l5t t$cJ;i . t$:)t_"cJ ct3:Jl L^J Ult ll (t)

t+)l-* y .,l:till .r:ro r_s.;i .ol.r.1r .pl.rJl ttbJL iiL:fl r"bill .r. $fU! "t" ,: ..:t

.r:,bLill "qJ !r--3?l ,l.J ;.6lill ..;'.* rJl;j ilt.. !t' .rcl3iJl o.qJ

.ll,ll ttlilL {il,: .inLiiyl iJ:Lill ",;!l !t (o)

I...1*4r!- Jr u.1A,.b

.:,1_21;$ o.r-ii .4tJ,-t .ci)-..' C. ",-lrll Ji4. j {is . (J-Jill JLn-yl .'hi (1)

.r(rr. iisi4ll i,r.iLnll ;i..i. dsJl ,llj.lt

r.r-:Jl a-s--. 1_,-.l 6;Jl gLl.rll ;i - i-sJl oir .Lii,r-i -rJ-i-tl -\

4.a. J Ji-i: *, i.-Xl ,rJc.,i. J+ cs.rJl 6JaJ+ll gLi;Jl 3o +g 61jl Jal"e *r.d-+b+

Lslr te." Jt ri i-(-ll tLl J*lJl C.l" lLlt 13 4Jsr. ;".<.,-g ,,+c.rJl ;,5t Jl

lJr.'.^.f<Jl Jl$! .1".j. Fr,{:l jil ; qS; arlill ('i E u-!Il LC.ri,U

4i)l!d r-;:l L? g,nlJl Ct+-J ." i-,; gUrlt

;Jl 6-.il;Jl 3La,l 3.t at3UsYl ..S[ill Jl;-'r ...1 ,r. J.-lt ,lL<,1! -Y

.ri L...:ll ,lls ,r*r, S:-+;i iilJl jr+i )ti c+.,-,r.'- (J]l' OU,rU.tt J.itt ti.t_i

fJ,- ,J.:31 .s ,rJe -r:leill oi-a '4- EJLj ;Jl ;,r.,Gll .r" YYV E.:tll u-+ p-

L .ry r-";Jl3 i,rL;Jl

"-+i ijlJl ,Jc f_}sJ +Jl! I { . :r a I .t (.'.L ,r;s lv o-)l.G*

i lt" y.f"q;u4 dl li.o,rlc .rj;itill ul.,;Ll:l JS,;! ol.rj. 1.. t-{l" r+

. aJl^ll Ll ^ - .i+'r.rr4 (JJl ft^ lr L'.rl c,lJ! ...i.X etJjr ijL-Jl 4_iJ y i-3lt

. Dji*Yl ",. &'Jl ;, ir-.:t|

\1vo alJ \Y. *r &Jilill ..p,r.rr E,i-! i.,-LJl iJl.ll "-. l,pll ;t-1i -r

(.l,-r Gr-cJl "ri ibJl ,Jc iiJ.rll s.t-*l.t Jr d :. tlr 6J.ll L.j<}tl "l+.tl a'e&eliJl Jli s;l.r! ,-J+-h \111 iiJ 1v .\t\y iiJ rv (,-jJ qiJjlilL L+!.i_,j

,,

. .. - i,iJ-Jl c,$"rJl ,rJc Ar"JlJ iIlJl irjt-iJl Jtr-'tJ 1^iJl -)r . . ..! .5 , ^.:

;e;;L^:iYl3 -rA!l i-l:...1 tiir t0Jl i-lJl Jlrn-J t4!L-'t3 .:rrl". 11 oJ-o i:J

f_.rl"iJl .r-l .L1jl .,.L J+ L- -:-i e*1-:; csi,s, t++t ,,-.*:tl ,r3;JL ,,::t1

t-{+ Lr-J":Xl i:.ltiiYl iJjli'll (,-iXl J-Jl .r.,!; A.;_ ,-Jl .:',rr!^.Jl ,11i.i...1 Jl

,l , ^! "o (Jjsll .,rt..tl i;l.r! "*l+t L,-.j}:JL;Jfl ariL3Jl ;,," yyv E.rllt j

J6l +."llli Lr.r3.r-',rs $l .'t: il .,b'...!l rJ*'sJ (,Jl iJilill -:l .--J q.sn.:lrl;,i

.:,il| L-t-,...t-,-#: i_iJJ.tL i--:j Ljb_.J'U_1, "!;, c,$.-rJt o_ra; g;

.3_*ij1l L.rl . ^'r:ll , lr_,rt1 ir- J-*:J L^ i++lJ-" j a.LJl l-^JJil ,pl JLAxYb

t. . . als' d,rjjl o. 1 alA

flS-l "L:>- Jt.r.r .r.4:3l l-rnrrrll.ot:r^-rlJ U-".tl .,J. rL-.$ oj.o,<F,l.{--L- dts .,j ai,,LJl .rci,.ll lJ<J d+l! sJG}l drLJl \ lvo iiJ \ y . ;;tlJl

. JlJ.,

6ll.t... lgt.L-Yl *.., -:. a*^: l..dI_4J ,,t;:itl c& G)l.nl c,jl< C _,

.slenl Jsl i* L{"Xt! .,t" r..,r, ! qll JL:.ll 6FJ, .,l:r.tl slJL! o!_i.6JlJyl

4. dr+l 6,i.'i l..ri L{:illi- +;)/!-.ll +* yr .tLJl tttXL a!L:! i,jr.,Gll

6!l .,-,--i1l .r-Jl qL ,_in.:ll iJjG.ll J.,-, rJL;. l.il !l A:Gr..,-. .rsie .r. lXj)Lc

dl Jl i:l -r..l"ill SJI c,l.l ilLJl 6r.{ .,-i L+-S cs_r__ jl .rlll;il| c1b o.r.r,sj

.;Jl a3.itill ;. yyv i.rLll .,j 4Jc r,-J,.-jll -,jlli,! s_-iXl

U ,r! - .ro t*,t- 6Ur:Xl -tr- ,-Jl 6JUll _L,!Il s-.--iXl dl s,l Jll _o

.lt_ll tt[JL L]t-j., t* _ ql a.ssl! 6j.o ,L;.i <-,6J+

\14. i-:,J \\11!,dujl -.tl i)_ ) /\y._-a/€ lr.:.r(1l ..,_i uJl JJ. _l

;l "lc c)t-"c 6- cFo-.ell $c q'l G,-Jl U+ff ;l *1. s-.r:tl JL^jn-yl .,j+.1;;!i.dtalll ailL- casJl ,,t...tl c,lrtrl rr,t- ii=:Jl ;Jtiill Jr_j,i +ttj

;-.S.atl

-,1-; l,l '+. r...t1 ,:..,11 o)L:.5jJl ,,J,iJl 31.*3 6ls?l ,rlc gttyl .,.0,

.iJ31;f l .u,.3 i-ilrll3

.i1K.iJl rl.-rl ,i$-,t ,;..rlt ;t ...1-

- ,jr!l Jl,3l JiL-r {.-._i A}rtlt #Jl a. A+l L. + _ yt!3Jl ;! :: -

pl;J,L "lal -,-l;l.r . .: -..y JL fJ_ii &11 o, .:,."._*tll cliJ| ;l .rs J,-=_j:{ia \1.\.,. aL,- d L4.6L;r ...:rLi;liJl La.r; J.rtlb ijctul q5J*,1l

$^,6illr - el+l l"{i tJ+Il e- a}.r .:'tlL i.ictLtl i<*lJl ;lq cl ; ""-,rJcL+iYt .:hj'Jb \11\/t/r ar_iI ,J;J_ill r : . -..?+^j _ o.r,!13,_i3;Jt ;1..61

1".tr'J'jl fiJ Jrl?^'t...Y I +.lc-

"+

o.rl.r-,;c t.-."1j;al &J 4l l!.:.r EJJ| .^tl

r...lid.r:.JJq,1i,J5

ot. it:x 6pJl c,.r:is LGg1I JiaX i*'L c.,'r'r'= u'oiJl 'vl 1'- ib't+*'r

aL.-r!ll .'t::.tl Ll TL i...<.-ll d-S- 'A:'!l'ljJl ElLill '-. Ji+ 6Jt i: \1tV iiJ

Y.Y. frr.-i[1-:-tL f<Jl li.6 ai-ctul isJ-iJl &uii-l '4]t+lt Jl leXl oJ';

\ riJ -itn:-.YLi+rjll uG,.'-q,Ltl L<dl {j-ii'lj*"| L"s '6J.Al-3jl J\\t iiJ

-rf.,+, ir. YY g-,rQ c,,-ii qjuii-Yl ix'-ll '-"-: ;i 'u,,.3 iJ'at!'ll J\ \ o ijJ

&A #l li-6 ,,! AicLUl dpl cnJ '''iii-:-Jl #Jl J-+l'Ln \114 ii-

i[ ,q.a;.r^fff #Jl +ni] 61Jl f-{+ c"l'l s-fl' LLJI Lt Xl c'"'$3 '"'oiJl

;'.r'i ll I { r iJ o}l A-,J.. r.,JJs 6;u*i- l-iJi .,-i il-rtl 6ii u! iPJ.ll 'i-Fi

'hirq$l

.,.l lr^rlb &itill ii!t; + ,'Lr,J"ll #l -lc r'ttll ol'": L^' .,1 e't^''r

d,-L gti,r, .-itnj'-)l i-!is.'- d cS-"": t'0-i1 ':jli '"-'"nll ,rr rJ"-'!llr 4n-Jj

jJl+J q.L.-.=iJl s-iLill t* bls";Fl a;'l ,r'ti.P "''Jr <., Jttll 61Jl ;1

A" l+-J .,.a,i,--:Jl ,r:Ul qlJ *i er,,;'it!'s 'ElG 'ifl s''-!Xl dl

", i iylll #Jl ;1 !! .+ t -;-i .9il1 iJ':lill f-" .11* e' '.r-Fll di' J-l

.Gii ..,-s. . Ji,.,.r-J r-,,,-, L. di-:6c r;JtL '6ladt gLl'rJl l'ra ..1c cs:ll

;1 - i-^iJl oi-0.L..-i d - u'ilI Jl dIJ '41-".,3 tJl lJ'a J! J""-- r

.g}'l+ll gLa.:ll 3o $.s1-rtl 'l.r! c4--13, Lr;rrl L<-- trt rrJl LLiJt

uJ" tl-31 .r-3 c-rJ..o .rjS,.r ,(JiJ,cJl ,i 6'tJl 4-'.J Ji-r r' i;'Jl .,Jc "i' J+ 6!l

.cl+l! ; o.<; r.5;tiJl .,-l Elill LGrlJ 'tl', W 9U,t LSJI tl"l JCJI

L#:ji L^,4i*ilJl <Jl J '-'1 ; rJ''.i gUJl li-a e''i #Jl Jtsc! .'J- ' i':+r

4Jl 6. g,,l.rll 6tul 3,0 i-.ll.istl rilr'ill 3l'3=:-l ,r" J-Xt ;lS ;13 4j13 'c)rt'l-

.s E/l n'lJ ,{-i} Jir-+;1 ,rl'r'tl ;r- )t" ct- r- J';GJLI! J'ill lili

fJL-..,:il .s,rle .r5l3ir!l of,^ J,*'eJLj;Jl ar''till tr Ylv 6'rlll (F r tF

L.ry+--;J"t3 i.rL-!l .;+3.jlJl ,rJc p-s tJl I{ :'ia:'t.rCtF' lv orLi-

irl+ yr"q;* dl li.o .,lc 'u-i t'r:Gll ,+ 6tiil JS al alJ'!* t"' l+'';.'r

-iJ^ll a.,L.- ?-=.J:t; crJl rt,Jl lt'Lill c.,bL;'J ':!iJ ajl--' ?l dn-E Y i-!lt..

l...4rrar" 9;*1a,,.rs

;.rul .r. o.rr 6r3-i t ,l ...11 EJul (J.i jl.:.i di x! .J)l-il-Yl ; ,srJl ; .ly.;lt

.,le ij,-'Ll,Ll .,-iJ.,-Il il { ?llJ c:r-.-11 ,<iSJ'Il *t+lt a'.+ \1vo a-1J \Y' inJ

\111 aiJ 1v .\1\Y i.i-J rv s*r}Iiltilt L{+J-.r J+,-"J,.rJl (Jr ilJl

oL n+rflr a]jhll iJjlill rl - ...'lJ t,.Jl -)Lr-l .r..r-=j.'lt:'11 dJi 8;l'rl ..rl+1,

Lifu l-{+ll i.=ul Jl$-r t-dl-}ir c,UJl o'r-a i...,-,t -,*-= i*i- J',-tl cL-.LJl

L-. (J-i ejJ-i:r c;J .,.i L(+ .t.J--ill 'rea.JL q;sll .19r 5L"XI|3 $Jl i-lr"'l

,r.-.!?t r-.ll .l.n.r. i;- .;,-fl c,ULJl .1'.1:"'l Jl LrUtt .i-:3.I+il ,,Jc J+

, *l-:1 u-.i- ,lt, ;J.l ar:LiJl ;r. YYv Ec[l "" t<+1" .--s--,tl i...3LniYl EJUU

;l e!+U :u+: .,ll ;JiGll -rl . ..1 +.r-+ ,3lJlJ.s 16,-! ,r",.I-rll .:liJl i,;lr!

a.-,; t^rl3--J t : i, dljj .:,L"LJ| .r! & ei J<l i.,-JL La.r3.r'-,r-i .ril-::

a)^ r- L t<+ls" ,.,/ ilJJl UJJni (Jjll .lLn:tb Jiilt i.-1,-" C- ,r,i."fu ;-irJfq

rl fJii dll c,LJ..Jl3 JJ3,ll ,+ rL.-Xl oi-r GJ*,,:J .ij.i:ll {iJL-i3Yl ' tr!:!l

.rs3,,Jl lJs3 4jl! SJL-ill d{LJl \tvo iiJ \Y. ;;l-lll atgi LrL--;-,-tE rn s-i

t;:: l.{j)l-A3r ,'blill qt G)l-ll ;,lt< :JJ 4i'b .,illje I { - L* ill.. (Ji qLJl

r.,!: Y t+,_Jl Jl .ir,l (,j<Jl .nrJll r]lJtJi it-! .i.rl.2)l ;lL t... hJ J!-?l -...'.-.

,rlc;)tul .,:. _.:+ Y; .ttJl ttLlL anLill i-,i- Jjlill .rlelJl .-L+a ar. k:}l! +

EJtjrJl .;r- 1L- lil Y! i.i- J,,-- "ryie ; tai)'L-c e- .'br:.tl aJ-3.r1 L^Ji, l('titLi."

.:,li ilul o.ra,r-i lt,t. 4a1 i[ c,!l-fJl etb o;.r-] 19Jl s,-!Xl r-Jl {:rio.Jilfl

.rrLlJl ; YYV s.rUl

"+

{lL r,.s*;fl JlJjll 6,--iYl dl -19l i.'il riJ.l iSJl

U,rL - r, l{,1. GLiill jJ- (Jll irjlnll rJ"3Ll ,r.-!?l dl ;L lrt:.el ;Jl

E.rl,ll .rn.,-ijl 6LSJ .tLJl f lLlln L.+ L. - t rrl i-.S--ll oi-o 'l ' :: +, r <J+

i-.$r.11 ,rJc ,r-..:Fll ,l .l': "':1 .lri,L.1i1!i \14. iLJ \ \t p,;;Lill u. -a/i

-.6/\ Y EJUI 6-ir ,*,:l-iJl L6J,n *,Fl ";-.-,iJl (-r) ...(l); i.,-t.Jl dill .r;13,-

. L_.r ^-u,,f...11 i,_J;,+ a!:411 l.,t-1! itlJl 'll,i.,l1..ll srlJl "-l+-,;l ,rJe *(-) ..(t),ri"q L" u.;Xl .rL d.r t<+L-*r.,ll LlJl A.-$l 6;3e ";g*'i

4l L+l-+(J:ll i-"UJl L*l :...r1 JUI (JjAr.,JlrrjilJl iJjLiJl -2lr-l .r'r."-i

..,1" ojX-.. 6..Fs-:.dl ,i. .,-i ;Jl ,-b'rl oJ.,- ,fJ'tll .l+ll ..'l "J" J+ ,"cs$fl

I... Ar- tu- JJA.1L.ds

"lL(

U .;t,,ll i_ill- .rjSll .,l:Jll .1'lJli! 1{ rl^ i-i.sjJl iJErJl .r'r,:. ,r..iq;i

ili .;-,, ,:r+ "il+ glJ:Jl Ji + &rJrl f<Jl 41,^* I ^r...- ilJl ;tS3 ,eJli

p 1)Ult .r. +:ll ;tSs \11\/t/t e;l+ i-i"tUl; $Vl oJ; L, *,Lll ..r'..11 e.

.r,;r-. q elttfl Ji"ll tli-;i <1,-L- 1[i,r., c,(...-'r;gXl ;i.-ib:i*Yl a-i.,.=.,-

.rJ-i.(l (J"-3?l ,Jl IJL?j {iL i.,-^jJl ;.iGll J.-*,lL .l-{j".f rJ-i.-o=i*"| t"4

,r:rill eL uL-l ; lg,t- JalJl uit J.,.-rt t+s -i d in".!--l ;.jrr.J .ijJiG

gllJl l.r.o Crtl q. &r,lll -<-.ll ;i U ,4i-L JEJ"JI a.--lJl Eil-ill >^-..,!r y

c{E + \1. \. . . o,rl$,- gJLllr ! t ltt1l ,ra.:Jl ;L,,1-i.1",!Xl 4n .i: .,-a

.iri:. tl ul ,lJ'rl ;*"i L.;--;c.r. +Jl ;j +_..

"" ,el!l Ly;s t1j)l c,l..r...!L

;L;"1 . ::tg i:,rtill L^-G, &',tltr irclul ftr! t_{+ "Jt &11 o".:,.,-o..,t1llldi i-+ l+;,: _.,r= ,Fl iliiYl c,lJrJl a+ Ji"i ":F-tr t$l r:,li cl l_-ir,

-ui c, Jttll al+l Jlri- l,.r^ - ^;.rSi.jJl3 oJl3i9 c5,i?l c,,,_-r .;Jnl

aJ,!11 f<Jl ,.j;-i.:!i 6-: ,JlsiJL,J+ aIJl l.ir; L;;i "1,r.1. L. .JJl

Jl : ^'t "J l e.:b ; lY - e!lr" .l.:Ui'Jt i+tll LiG Jr,,tllr ajcUll f lrli {$

ot"+.r" iicttll ,Jc,Js-:-Jl C$l -rlt." J&-l ji 4e,r ,rl,rJl lL.l J: ^..,

a$,,ltl f<Jl ;! tl lia .4:le ii-.:.Jl Jleill .-' ... r^X I ,, o ^'r ,rl,=?l .r-Fl

-jrL?ll t{i *.!ttll ;.r:tl.ll {+'"j,ll ,+ iLUl ,;hll 4nj: (J-i aj.ltll 3tir.r C Gi ga

,ric. ,r-i ;.5l3Jl a.!t.;nrl iilXl ;1 Lr.rG- il+.* i_rl+'t biG.,rill .,.,-311 dl

4l? .JlrnX; ^Lttl ibll yl"rl c,.: Ll-rll t.r-e- A-.-iXl c,lri.Jlr.-;,-il|

,/-" r,l;le!" {lJl rJ:titl ..l,.-3'rl J-llJ k G:l .r ,.iL+ ;1 ,.p.: clJi3 .6;S-;Ll

+ ,jLirl JS "i _.,!:"! tlll g.:;s".-;rdt ;L.J- Er:i Dti -,'ri..!l t$ irtJl4JL,-]Y dllir;jL-rl di.=S Y l:lt ^'E)L., )ttli n_€ (J.--ill JJl ic, .l,};r:Li

irr gl,-j Li 4i+ ELIJI c1lijrq d il 4iG &r.,.Lll ,<-Ll al-l ,tl.4Jt ttLilL

:Lr-,i .r."! :.^ tl i'L= ;.r -,-Jl !i,{l 4-;j'i .i-. ri l-: li*- a-l1 4i!-i n+L

J.tlt