نقض حكم ببطلان صحيفة الدعوى لتوقعيها من محام كان يعمل مستشارًا بمجلس الدولة: الحكم المطعون فيه لم يعتد بحكم الدستورية العليا بعدم دستورية المادة ذات الشأن بقانون المحاماة رقم ١٧ لسنة ١٩٨٣

vLt

Y. . . ai!,J J:Lo iro t. i-..Lr

LJ..:-cJ {-SJl ,..r.1,-r t-L L<J,-.-:.ill L:J $.^s. /,t .i::...11 ,* ...11 i-tir

ff l .*- .i.SJl 1.,r...,-i- J .,+iE e-j- 3',1 L. ..LJl ,i." ,il,t:! Ji,- /cpJl .1.r . ..1 | rJl ...!l

.;1.rJl .rr- cr',r-"3 .r.5-:,-

(.lrl)

ar5L, :,arl 1f a.i-J VA\ fJ OrLJl

s){Il .rg;JsuJl Ai.rsJ-o,15uc,.r .iL6r ^. .lte lrr i .,F$ .AJiLi .fu-19io (Y .t)

.(AJnEJl 6*.r.L3 d tb.iJl :sFJJlJl r-r. 3gcr f> .r6g[e.Jl ^ i- * U){L.,

JUI fll ; rl-J; rlj,- p"r-c. .i,=jY rl d,rti; u^ L;;-.r 1,r,, fJl (t)

dnls Jr +r'iLiJl jslJlr iLirjl ,rJ";'Jl Lra.-,t^ ...r1 .+*rll i.r-j+ll ; or*:r:l

.llJl tt[i,lL cxi JJ,i ..-;iill i-^s- lLl ,s.r,cJl eJr.rl 3J3 ,r:-- "_rJ, ^ + (+L-

iiJ \14 Ji JIJ-ilL Jdl \1V1 iiJ tAJ f1 t.la-;:,U.b; ilt ^"li-"('Jl

_\tt^

\v & iL"tsll 4!G; \ o t LtuF-J tJri lJr-!l LrilJl i4<Jl ,1. ' ; (Y)

aiJ'cJl i.a:--;ltl- 6jL.^iJ,l . ':ll lJe + iJ|,frl fJl .rlscl 1.r-c . \1AY ilJ

"+ lL".! iLJt L-++ irr .;''... - J"+,jK ll^ ^.r. I (-rirr! is.rJ;bl ix.,. tt-l

.,Jc' LJj-Jl tJ.rf ,1,--ill lja;L_"r* 1,r..c alLn + I { rJ_,.j,-.r p.,, ,r-:-!11 8.rltl

,,.:.11.! ilc .'Gi .6J,j; erlil JlJl tll J. 6r . :'r: - JLJ-r u-;ut

\1V1 iiJ t fnJ Ulrll Lr:-Jl A.SJI JriG; t.1 ;.rl1l 6-i LJI -\

i-sJl tK--l ai |.Jlc \114 i-iJ \11 r3r &rtilti L-rr,{_-"ll ' ".,.:- J JlJ.ii JJ4tl

.....i-ilSlL il3.rJl c,l!^!... C+-?l L.;t x-.iilL k l_,1_r".r Lri--Jl 6rlcJl u-i

psill .r. Q-,tj -ll.1r..a lJ4 i'i! Jl &rL!,r" "F. ,;1;*.1 il1,1 gSJl .rL ,.-u-.f.1

v! o l.'. &yt &.l. ilA

irri-Jl i^S--Il ; #Jl _p.r,-,rL;. _r,* cl ,rJ. J+ (.... fJl ,rJ;lll

Jttll fr*ll a* lrlijsl <i.A;13.* pe i=jy rl aJnG ss o-, L*-p-,-a il"? tit Jl

ill<lb iLJl slLl... &..+l tjL f(Jt tJir a..,..-Jl EJ.,J+ll .,n #l l.i.a _,..iJ

il3rll ,1" +\.^f "c d;;;i ta-:t_1r.r3 t-6.cb.il ._i)ljit;SL_fl ,rLe q.:,-3

f J,r+ #Jl I j-o -p.r.,- + i-i"L- c,it5 Jr ;- la-.Je i,$tll i.rilllt ,SlJ.lr

4li.})-,5 (J.i]J L* a]i-::.i & cj,-ill OJ r+" a.,.'tn-i,ls it . .-.6J1...:-L LJJj*,Jl

ar9,Lill

".gd L:rr*a fJ.rf fSJl .r1 c.LJj pjY'1r oiLii g.*rlj .r.;i csJ t+F

6l ,rJ" g"-,lLXl lJ.6 J- {3..ti ',-*-,-., )l-i o-xL et-.rtl ,r,Jr:ll a3-,ll ;. L3l ao-=

41.-rj tLJl ttLilL JL:- J-i 3o3 .,- l L"S-* tLl ;xJi; s:LS 3J3 .slr,r

.1F,.$.tnb; a"SJt

Lri.-Jl i-SJl ;e r.rl . ll laJU ,:-, iJ d*_!,JrELll a<_Jt ;t< jl _y

L-yi".r 1.4 \t1Y/o/\1 {*l+?., \y AiJ 11lJ L-;|J.i*Jl (5r,e,l u_i l+.l,ll

ti*Jl i.g; +lL _u*intt3 \1Ay aiJ \V*JiL"l ^tl,j}LiiF \ o ;JUl Lr-j

l4 'JiJil) i-'..,1.r ,-l.ei i.S-- tLl 6r,cJl i.iu-,- ;t-t- ,"-;, \lty/l/t to,l:.,

fJ,? (J;ill LJI li-6 ftLX iL".l (iirJl ,r-l+-: 'lrr .;.r.*^ &-:;15 f L--.*

1-xJl ; "f,:iu 6-'+ L]b -;Ul .J1" 6J*€ Y l(JI l.r.o;i iJst* {:r-JJj-J

6:r:i C--1G;le L-e:-.Jl fJ+ f<Jl ,l JL-", -;:1,";l e- a-rir AJtiJ ull:Jl

$ arL<] 4j!i (Jl++I ._iii :+Jt .1",_r.-eil i_i_,-_ll gU_' pJt) C.iJt u^iJ

.&,rrilt ,ill.: (,.i itii

A;S.JI

JJ-iLl rl .i''r...t1 ,_,...11 o1:6ill -'.,Jn:ll Et"-3 .6ls?l .rL g1l"yl .r.'_,

.d3lJl ,u,.3 iril3l13

. LK^iill cal .-,rl u-ij-l a,rUl Lrl ..:-

I . ' :i- JJ1. Jr l. LJs vtl

,J.,-=:: -;lrj'tl >l-s !i,',-",tll i<Jl 4,,4 A,,i L ('L - iErtt ;l .l=

;<J.i.ll (+ 1ils.,-rl ;yllJl .-.r+ \1AV ai'J " 15.pJl Lt3i;teull ;i i

if +LJl t*3J L^.4;r:^r....1-{f ,s"},J'C l-{-lil!ilsJl +ll"l t.6.GJr,'l.ll

6,lll r,.Xl kr ,t-lsJl ir" 4Sliil c,,n-l sJlr i-+Lill Jilr'iltr L"{i+ drG- $!

rso.cJl iit-,-;)tL- ta.G ,'. r-'l.ll isJ-'Jl c''i'r ' 61''Jl LLi! .rJ! L^e';'r

;,l ..!LtL l(.J . iJ ^ si: ,<r,EJl Li1s-6 Jtt- iJl r-,-31 .-S-= i."-+-'.'s

;,^(- o,r;$ .*.'..ll 1;31 .,i .r.,..r i;- gl-lll .ful -1.":-! {PX 6J-c Jl 6rl.cb

Jlill nt:ctu cs.r..F,g Lau ;t-!Il '.S,-rrJl fliJli \lto/\ \/Yt C''Jq

\\\./o/\.,r3;rLJl f-<Jl Lar-;;J.rUl +<3;Jl ,:nrt--'*l -i lirit-iJl

........... t'r .s[::-YL .;tjcttll dirii-'b i]Gll J \ 'V;iJ '--" '-ilj::'":L

,r3 ;.:LJt r<Jl LaG Ju-!-tl iSJ-,iJl c,iiij-l L"S .6J-itnl J \ ' v LiJ

.-iu:i*,IL L,Lic,u"ll 44rij-b J \ . A 1!J f') .-itji-r-yL \ 11 \/\ \/Y t

-..':i,-,rrl c,Gl'.';...Y1 Lr-;;l:r.r -il '.1r"'!l i-S-.3...3 1'1i:J " """'

,siu J \.V ir-J . .. ... . , . . ,rJ.., q.ltXi*Yl :l.r+ lJ+ \11Y/\Y/Y .,jl

,'g.r;l .^tl q.iiij,Jl ,)-sJl 'lilt \ 'A AiJ '" ' ' (5n., q'ill:i-Xl

Cr i: il ii.-,-.'..,. JlLr.r \11\/\\/\t ,\\\'/a/\ ' ,rs a-'-. ;r "l.el i-6<-si op

k*i c',s.,l ;i-u" CEll c-.r33 .,^iJl .1.-A #l l.ia,rl;t]stUl nlt 'alrcJl

L-J= c,.r.r-=-i ;J.',j,- 4i-|i .,-i al-ll .Ja .,! A'Lll '-;Ji f<Jl '-;nll 6'lJl

t{i'rJ qqXl c*-.;ill k+i-r :rL rt

e$"1 ; "[1] r+Jli !";t'lll f<Jt ,sl'AL"tUt ot-i L'";! ":'-'- .r

,.+-t ri-! ar,,tll f-ll ,t Jt'ie ,:llJ ,rl-* ,-t'r arilill ;.Hi"r ci 'ti^.-ll J'l^ll

irr.rr..,^ J^,: ;r< rL=- ",. t+,+3! i=.').r ,-!1 ax-- fll-i (J3,cJl i-it--,- ;)l^"il.t-Il ,1,:t! .,,-. \ o 6Jul fsJ it-"-t ;uurt ai{-- {n"JL- J.}3 ilJl 'J'l+"i

i..SJl ,..p;,rr.^l! #JL;.rtll oir L5f--l lJ+ 'L;-dl iii \tAY A:J \v 1U

6.jll J-?l l+<- Jt".l ts.-,-. .ri 615 L* \1\Y/o/\1 i*J'-' rrUl L-:u:-'rll

. {,;3i ..,-r. . $,.,..}-J f<Jl *11ei

YTY Y. . . :i4 3]r. J. r. !.d.

Lri-Jl i.S-ll idl.!;r. lt 6.:tll ;.,-Il ;i e,lJj .r1.r_-,rr:ll ;l ...:-.s

i]J \'\A f"J ;;Lllti i-r*-^+Jl ,-.i- 3 _rl_5s1 J, Jl \lV1 aiJ t f.ir I I t- ll

Ci.+J Lil Jj."i:J! tel..,l-,,.r LJi-Jl 63tr.r.ll .,-i a.S.'ll tlS=i ;l ,rJr \ttA

4-:.fl Jl JiLi.ri,- t-_:l-.r fr,? f.aJl .,1" +r:-,, .....iit<t! ilJl c,lt^t_._

p.r-- .rlc -..U :: e.l .,.L J+ ".....9-ll .l-,j.I Jtjtil psJl .r" t+1L;l.p p.

il,r+ l& i-iY 3l i";G ..rs ,-. L-,Len-a fJ.,i lilJl L_rJ,:-Jl a-SJt j. #Jl

rit #l li.6r i*",J| ;.r,,r+Jl ; r<Jl lJi --jnl JEtl ls,tt O- iU"r <i.,r

du;l La-L. r,r3 l.Flr,ii -iliiL ftJt + qi.,-r intsur iJ3Jl .:ttl_ 6-+l

"i. t+L- c,il,< Jr F I 6 j!. Asrrtll +illJl 5lr.lr iCJI -,l" qil"r n€& odl J-l:+- ir. i,;t<;l .:: oJl..'i.L Lr}:-Jl fJ+ fSJl l.ra _.s.r.,-

fr,n #Jl ;1 ellj 1:Ys ojt-it y;,ti ,r^ t\ ,s\ *xJjl {.!.=)t.,- .,i:,1 L"r 6i-i,r

qi+J- .r:"i )Li o * =ru !r:lr frJt ;. L;f" rr,^l &itnll ,r-r.p., L5g-.r

. -.l*i- r-l sn3 ..-iJl i-S- tl-i ts L!.E-i- r]:l5 _rls.sJ-. 6l .rJc ,-_r[iJl l.ra;.

d q; ;r,J"tl -(Jl ;t<3 ,ciJi ;L( tl .lr ...x. ,G13 ir. i.5Jl 41",i tt ll ttLJL

{:.J 1 fiJ L::)Ji-Jl (5J-cJ (5i lj!.ll Lri-Jl a-SJl ; rJt . ^tl #.JL J:.J

\V fiJ ILLJI nlL!.r. \o ;.rlll .r.i L3_e*J 1.rn \1ty/o/\1 i--J--., J \y

ii1-.- g)U- cr;-iJ \11Y/1/i p::rLl <1^-+lt 6o.r+JL -r.ri;Il3 \tAf iiJ

4n::lr'i.*J fJ.ei u.;.!l,l uJl li-n fK-X iL"-l i--. ra "[i i-.(--. 1Li r <.r,.c.,rll

JLjjI fll !1.6 6l .:i: - (5j,--., L.b ,;Ul rj.l" r<;,,+ ) -(Jl lji Ji il}i+.FJ aJ*ilr e,Jb.rc L-e:-.r.ll fJ,t 15Jl Jil JL-.! ,r;.:l_.;i g- oF g,-_rLJ

4-?.L.,lJJ ,.i ...11 llel ra-ii -:.r. .31 t+ &_ilill J+J.:

""

iL ri $ i6l q.,G iJl

.:.,lll ..,1i...1 .,nt? r=il