نقض حكم يلزم الجمارك برد رسوم تخزين "حصلتها بالزيادة": القانون قطعي الدلالة في تحصيل رسوم

11t

tr r . ii,..r J:|b Lr" 1 a-.-ls

i-"SJl L*,-:- J :tll ,r : i l.l J-,l, .!a-s-a rs-!r

^JiSJl

Jl .+,': . ..tl Jn_Jl i*l_iJ.

-lJi ,r-:--,-fl ,r-"--l , j.y-.r lnll ,:- ,ci.y:J .r-e /g.1jl .:..r . ..tl iJl ..,!l L_J;3J

.(,JrLlLll ri*rll ,l.l i.sJl ,*.Li,

(\Y\)

arsr, :.arl 1y a.l.,-J ltAV fJ OrJrJl

.(o'1.r.,.,,rilll A3,.rl'! ( 1 )

.ri" 311.:Jl .!.ai ,l ,€ r...1 6jcJ, ai,JL 3i q:L 6o:Jl .l.- f .,J+ll e,;pll .rFXl

.(r-nrjS.ilt dJtdJsJl Air-F) dlg+ (f )

{,JJS-Y| (,jC" (Jll r,5l3Jl .Jjl . .rt1 .rJc tait: -:. ..1 .i.1,- jJl oLJ;ll a.:r.rlj

k;-,'* .r. .ta::Yl 9;E; lqi ii)j Ji ;+i-ll 1,-rFd i:l+.r" 1!i t*- .rr. it-,J13

cJL- ' r tl {J-si oi-i j \11\ aiJ 1v eiJ JIJ-lll a. Ayl iJul . clli i.tc .Jtil l--el

,r. l+l+'L---r,-'U;t, ..^:.tl ;t5.;- cl i.S-ll oja.l.:-" (J.i uill - \

f;.il| , ' ^-" "l ,8r'..1 c<-rc'l1 tL err;.lt 3i tL3iJ Jl . " )Li 4i- Jlll ,Jc ilYJl

.g g.! r3,=.3 31 .Fl &r,"i .rb n.lSr L;l s-,.11 L1l J- ,'i qi"

A'L-i: j \11\ ;t...1 vl dJ rlJ'll (.].. tj'Jl ;rul (J-i.,-:ll ;l ,Fl - y

!+rll - il,iJlJ LJJj(*Yl jrl-.J.:, , ,a_,-Jl J,,13,"r i.:.jJl .:,1. r:. ll !., -r

arjJl t*_r J[.,--i .,i ir4tul ii-l .,JE i$Jt .,.t3 _ (Jir,cJl ; ibll ,J"

.t{ji!l C.Jti.r- Jlir ilnJl ri LJ.rr(-!l ;q-;! a;j i.ll-, JS .rJ. irrUt

y-F a:l+.:" -i<il -1" f lli {-i-{ <!;.s.6.Il c,LLJl 3l -Llt tj-}b-l "-il . ' ill lr. L^5 -,-131 L*il l'.+-)il ar" ,tx;tl e,*,b.r" rli i:)t: rl iiJjJl

I. . . lr* J"L. u. I L"Js

,:*:nt JL-cl Jt'jrr t{-)lr-l (J.i JiL-Jl -t ^ 1 Ut'i''. jJ ":- ':llir - rl"i: " tl

.+U*f l u,it^ .,3 t-ijllJ

arS-atl

..L;!.ll ,l .;'r ...t1 .r-Jl o)E ('jll '.J-!jll gt-3 6l5Xl ,s.L g)l.Yl -' -

il3|':Il'l.''.3 <*31;Il3

.LK;iJl <r:l . ',ri ;Ji-l .j,tll n! 3J-

J---ii - JlrrXl -rt-s n+;rJ"tl f<.-tt ar"4*L,rlc - ytljJl ;l '4-3

cg-rl :r \tt\ ir.J lYY' 1.s-r csr.e':ll c'-L-3i t-^r ': arFJIl a'S1.-:Jl ;1 "'l

p-,r ur -,L.^ l! 4-,-i-,-:. #l *Jl"i {i4tul i<J--iJl (J.lc {i:lJn)l Lrr<-1l

tef-,f!, f :;cfl ..,ru ,tl-i- ii,,-, t1Jj3..|= 4e'r e':l*;lL l(.lt'^- .-,Jl ':p-Ji:ll

#Jl &Jti ar" It eil;l., a-,i- $t.ilt o.r:lei3 tr'-,:Jl oi'a L^.,i t1- t 1VYA C-lr" 'r3"

LrJr(-!l ,Li- aF ftl,,; -L-ia1l ;. iJl "u c.,.r5i.'l t+l ellll'r:fo t'lU,

c,l,l;-! ',.ill .rJc cri rr!3 \11\A/\ \ L91 -U:L! J! iJL-;Jl c''r;g $r 6J--+l

frr L0." l,{j-.}it fi \11\/v/Y1 trJ ailill \'el'rL ;'r:rl ,Fl ,J'-ill +"ll

iL,.-,',.. tXi ,i-.-:-*: JS: rJ ijc'ttlt ASr*il1 ;1 .r'e':il .t'; \11\/Vr'LVJ

u \11\/vA. sj-- \tt\/v/Y1 J,. iJijJl ,i. arF ts--J q:+ YAlY,v0

flJ*:ll oia;1 Cr- ":-,rb d--''i5' oY-\YY,Yo' 61.."' 'rt'r-,rJ-e te :l ,' il La:l

,lFl .r "i,;;*r !3'Jl i.rLlt f<J i.irlE fL \11\/V/\A 1e.r 1..,1-:'-l o'i-;

u-J--:Jl J,G-J i.,r.,- i;ill c,LaJl ii,.:: .:9.r - rt s..L.Jl \11\ Ar-J V1 dr

,l;.. t o. L^lr! tJ,i LS-:Lt c*S.= 6J,cJl :'"GG ilriJlr L-rJK-Y! ;ltJ'i

&lJIl a$-,-t! .gry,1'C ibttJl a$Jl llet! t+;:rl ;r Js-'j-Jl -.'lLU

Fr SJI ;r3J-,- eiJb J- It El';u A-,r- it'iJl o'ril+is a-':-= tlvYA a!- LaG

Jt ArJ olt t3r.-ilXj.-:tr #Jl lli iF- Xl i<>:Jl c.,nij-! ':l'r-Jt iL;

vov dr -itrx-JL alctul <r,-iJ! 4:-ii'G."1 Ls LJJ<-xl 'il""'t "l a^s-'" ll-l

Y'..;Uu9Luil{.4!a 111

i-X-Jl c..<- \1tY rL",_".t*;l a!" yV e_,Jl-:-,.J i-S.-_l gl.i fLi JtA i.LJ

#Jl lr-a lJ3 ii4tLll is.-iJl .-.r.t^.-iji_:*Jl f=lt r ---u3 O{il:.. .t ...X1 ,;i}

.ib 4.l.i,.,+,LU #Jl r6ni.,(J,rJl t_{+.r.!1 sJsL ltgJl c,..r-i3,_,:iJt &JL

3! ill 4r-!J ^J[: I 4-;L crJJ-s ;-rJ-,-:1. i_iJ- .," i..S.-ll oj-a ,r.le .;-tll ,_;r.c,

. t-{:'t, otl$Jl

d i Li llr cr,,Lall a.i.lt I ^ 1jG ,.,r,,!11 #l ,1" i;ttll oL. ...: L ,l ..-,^,r

aJtj \11\A/Yl tr: (-|. ar-j,-Jl I.JF-JLlt;-r..,1 !l+,=...,.,-l(,l etlj 4j_,,.l,j

tE-Xl a..,"j.i 4+ u-{jii crJl \ t1\/v/\A tJi .J," uJ- J , -Li.ll f+t_il .kJlvi dJ JlriJl ir. .,J3'rl i.rU ; r,i, iJiill i<sr )1"- il,-!l oj-o,l;l ,r- 6r; +Il

t-!i. J.,-$ {...t-* L* L^-Jl c,,)L,Jl l-61i L: gtli i,-.- t4:;.r.-,rJl \111 ;r. J

.r-;ni

;15 u.t- 4.,i i-SJl 6J-o er .:; d rJ,il| ._,1 cJ.Jj .r.,.r_ dJl lJi;! e+.,.t

6.uiJl 3i cL-.r'rl Jl-+- )Li 4i" Jlll u! ilJJt ," ltl+ L-*-'t=_;tr.,-itt

,Fr; rr. ;4 L"jl 3.-rll lj-a ;l-- ;X <]* f.p! , ^: ,1.r4:_! sJ,cJ, d..lc

\1tl iLJ V1 pJ Jbill ir" *'$ ;rUl u-i .,-Jl ..,K.r d+ g4J .r.1=.3 3! "Jl- alji.JIJ LJ$S-YI jr',+-j. u6.'aiJl Jl.,ti-J a+jJl crL,rU J,Jsj .ij .

+ t t,- j,Jl c,L.r r ll Li.r.r: ,t-:*;,;i s! _ (JJ..cJl (J.i ibJt ,Jc ;a-J.Il

rl a,rul ," iL;1Jl + Lr.,- j;Jl c,L.dl i.ir,.r: ri5.:*"j ( I ) :,;tll J,-jll

Ey +Ji rrl JJ+,-YJ.:Ll ..ll ll iuLlL all ..,Jll flIj-l ,t{nl e,:uE.r. eLLJIiilt rl ill ..rll &*.r- Cl+ ir" +"-Jl c,)lL4lt t_s+ tr 1!i +,+*;,. 1)...*"f l

Jl-:.1)U tljli.ll il. ritl yo r^rr etli3 Jil t-{ii t .iJl tJJ..: ,ta:ol 6.1yb ; pl*l

.'"j,-:Jl Lr"r J[.6.--l eri ilitUl t+i.-l ,.jlo {NJl ,r,,ti -...srts]l ;;t .::.!l Ji

,l-{iiYl e,JU u'. ,.:Ii3 44.=Jt Ji LrJi(-yl ;tl*";l u_.;,., dt_; JS,rJ";o;rl

y_,ri U+ & -i(rl ,1" fql 4+."r 6.ra_:.6J1 c,LLJl sl 4lLtt la_)i,l ;

. :..11 lJ4 L^i-i ,-lil L.-6-i I ( r, i.: aF ,t { ilyl 9*:E .* pll t)l-: Jj i+-i_Jl

n-t:Il JL"cl lllLrfu td-)E-t (Jj,-lit .,Jl :r ^ J 'rtt+:.,-y (J:- ,:Iir _ al.....i...r.1

l'.. A:ld3rL9..1a,.A

6*--r-, tlq;i ;lslt J- c+LJl ,133 'elJj;LS U',!UiIl ;:r.r 6s;i:tt3

erli aLS 16, .:;-J-Il is-j--:Jl lr ^ut"'i, 1t;Jl J=* alL"rJl ; a:-:r-'Jt

fqi {,+- J,., l+.. El Ii..1,- jJl .rL.lJl i-!ir,:,-i5:-r il a}"r \11\A/\\

.r , -u ;ul lJ.6 4,! ar-tll #Jl .illi ib . \ 11\A/\A (J.i 61 .e-,Jtll l$ c,"

.13.r ,rlirJl fr+J! ,tdll tJB . \11\A/Yl 1.* .r. "4'-,Jt t*-r gti;-l qlq

q.;n Qljj L-,4.ij.'ti j',Elr JJ,jtill -ilti Ji Juq {-:!-i EJul .:!i tt<-1 eGlJ,A

.a,r!ll .,tl"J silJ L6rr:1'I o+L .u" '-.,Jl li{J