نقض حكم بتعديل قرار لجنة المنشآت الآيلة للسقوط بترميم دورين بعقار إلى إزالته حتى سطح الأرض: تقرير الخبراء أحاط به البطلان

\TY \

Y. . \ ai.lt J+ .rf.l go Y[ a.urLr,

;JLJI L-g;aJ aX.s-ll u-ijr .ilj F "3.* r*1 /rt.r'1 ...11 J+Jl i-*U,.

i-aJl ,+J vls, jL-:l- 1al.yl ,r.."-.1 ,,lrJ *:-i .rJtr .J)l-- ,r.--,./;-t .+.':...t1

.;.r1.!l ;;6.r-". 3

(Yo^)

4rsL-oiiJl Vr ti,.,t \Att ^ : ;.rbJl

.(!d4ll 4rJl c.r. 31 i,.c : ArLll .,.6 ru,a-rJl : ,jd4ll JJ+5 L..J.i, ,.,-6.i1 (l)

.r+-'r:: ,,s+ 1ll.' Ji d l<Jl 1,rc .i-3---Jl ir- l.r+L" i ri: ^ i.--Jl . i,r i.r

. J.tll j {.1 . ^irI &ii f,rE ..Jil .<,,.;J':jY .-,1J...,l sl&,;iIL n ].ll

#Ld ;JJJTJU t e -.Lr..,, FgJr;jll i-qs-rc .r,H-laJl r-rrrr 6,1i.c,L+! (I)

.ril.r1l ;pli os l {rt^l...} {rl}3Jl yrrd,;J.GJI #t 4. oi:olr3. Il

.

-;ti i!l* j, . l.{+ ijJblb , r :, L-r. lij.rll ...-r.r rsr4Jl ,-Uc Jr.i..l

.l5ul ,r, .lr#L ijl.ri-tl .rls- .k+ "-r:- ,-;.*r. Jl t6j" 4*tX jlJ- pc .L e;./l

.t<* crl_,ll 'l.r.l <..1,e .,.-.^: ,pJl i.i.irll

rtA.rSr-r : Li.r-13otl .y-rilt ,J*nLr, (.:ij,ll e1.1.1 i,p.r .n)lly .Cr!f! (f)

: crb3yl dELd a-r.gsltJ t6 :Lr...) tjE4jll id-r6 .U**5ll Jl-.-sl A1lil)

.rel;.riJl r.r. rr .,.i : ;.;r.rJl .P1,.,,"0 j

;-' r..:.ll .l+l .,J. f4.-$- Jl. t:l .,<.;:n arr,r 6, iiL:-Yl jl.r+ p- .'l *Jl

r++Jl Jl+il 1s--itl .t<+ g..+ll 4ila J,+*-r 6rEJl j iJflL +;--,Ftiil

.r3.r-,;L .i"(-ll r41.c, lb 4-i-i {Ja fiitiit .+tp .Lr.Ul Er-5t,. - g l,l+ 6rI

3i.rs.rJl oja.p 6oJl g3-:311 .r;G itl* "..d iL:lI €,1*=)t JL *.Jl i{-.rl*xl &,jxl1 "j1 .i-{lL -$irl ,-.i:ll .,-i-i r+ rlc al.:15)l-Jl "lt ijo.Li^

iiJ '\1 a$iLilb i:l-;--)l 4irs&r c,ti?l ;rru ir" 1oY ,\tA,\t. ,lY1 , \Yo Jll

.A.iL;ill il.t*tl 6;G ;- 11"\ iatll3 ir,*Jf L+ \CoY

!. . \ a:s J+.,+r u, lt a-+

JiF,jJt iJt rXl : yj+-,-ajJl L JIJ',,,-o : flts.r.X I 'rJ4rl, ts.s .c,t-i! (1-t)

,C c{tjJl a-iJr i ig *+4.,,J-ill .,i JJ..,,4.IJ| : JlJ'l.ill s}r.r) UFGJI

(.:.!:i,Jl JJ-J-$ Cl a-.s.{l rLi3-rlr <.lr=r-:Jl r!o-e .;r.ri3n ;3;-r 't,.}lg'Jl

j Q:U,ur gre3Al i.as.s-c .<63a9-r gtirr 6t5.r '<.lt+iJl ,*ii 6)llerr

.<iJ.$l ,;r,rlig ilgJl f.4s ,f I ( -'r^ r' ", (;JriJl #t*. ,3s : stJiyl rJ5t,..,r'o

31..!l 6:tl3 c,.,.c. ii-l i-tJl ;1 ..Jq L(J-lc clj .J.l dl ^r ':l ...r.,rs.,r .lsJl (t)

'\5 f'r:lt 1Gr3 iJ;lI '*' ^^ u

l{-,1. ,r+ ;l .,-?l Jl ilL-Ylr r*:Jl }J+ j;,l kl Lr'-srt il* (o)

.W! '- e :'l ,.lrll i'+Sxl !! {i'rj-'3 ajiu rrrS Ji '4t}:; k'ss .:r ta.l:'i;1 trJJ

<:.llt- ri o un-o! 3i .rFl ;)tLL .r*Jl .:F,Jc 4lt:3 J i.<Jl .l'-r,: (1)

1*-Jl c,L;l;) i"sJI Jr,-=: -.3r5.o1.r3'" -4:li f<Jl (J.i.:+ ilJrll ; r].lrll

,1r-G rr ^<^ ;ts )ls t<+ csr-,ll .t.!b sJ:jJ:l

l-o : rl.J.rfJl u. Jtlts : 4::!tJ-gi> qar)U.J), fa .r;lss'Jl gIIaJr UXL1 'c'Lf! (V)

r LAugr-s : <ir-5..0'r-o ,:t+iJl 6J*it-!6, rt*{iJl er-rrr';r5 -irS*al 's.r

: l3lj. yl #r...1 ;..,,.ith r6':Ll "r ejesJ,l loss-o.tJ{isJl Jt4.si a)lLJ,

.ncl.:.iJl :JJ, d ' 6,.:Jl #L,,,ao i

alJ*xt, L oL U es -rr-. riy 6Jl3Jl j,l *-ill J! t+ *- |JJl n^{-Il jl .,.j,r:

ilL=l ,'ltiill ,,rn n)14 .oil .a-SJl f++$ o- ri- 4i pE3 <1 l3eK1 | JL.-cl "r

*;;.ryl+ .c)l!-;ctul '''' "r fliJ #lll l,i^ J! + J,i'Lll fJl

pLi c,LJt 4.1 {.'. r., d cJl5l o'u-;,,lll ;i ;l-p1L c"Llll cllSrlil - \

L"S'-+ ql" ti ol f- d, "qrL Lu* a.r'.-..lt ","-i3s: '.r-'-L!Jl uj+r;

il- ++ d &r .tJt:Jl o,r-;r,-U.tt;J,::l r:1-'-l .'L J,tlt lii ,ctUl 1Gi

.41 i.'JL,:',tll &,i

\ rYr Y, . \ ii4 J:'.-.J.,, ij Yt alrl.

iJ.ri ; a,:-., L r-=*J; Le1-i ,jJl c-. s ol+.., 153,.cJl -,.*tic J:.!.sj - Y

t{-.,c -lr+c]l <J.rl +lY ,;lt ts;./t t,;Li L-yr fr.* u. ri t++ itjlJb

;i.=., iiri JJ*l ,-e Lt; -or. .,:Jl 6JL..J| .,i <,i ]l ,",,1-c, t-61i - ;J*ij ri !l3J

.5'rrJl ,l.r) 4n*.4 J*+;l efi.": )G - Le fu?t ;,c LLJ| ..;till ._iJt - r,-rj

J*+ EJJ*n+ iil-:. .Y1 o1 . t - i.-.+ k*,

6Jsi-.J nL-':Yl irJ'ti.r" \oY,\tl ,\t. .\y1 .\yo .rl;ll ; udll - y

\1cY aiJ \1 a$itllb ,c,L*illl3 .:Ll!l ;;t! o!6J'...., o- Gl.s L3 g-L;.,,yl

AJ.IJI &J,rG; \Y\ E.:Ul +_Jc c..^i LJ,l .: :ll c,l g i 1Li Er.,iJl f:L+

g -Y.,1 .:-"t; ,1r.1 j* d{^. r.]ll ,j'Li f+'d,l_,:,:ll ;i _1" - J+_A.':r.:;tl

C--j J,ri-;:.!'Il uinl Jl; .iil,j_-)l 6J-d u;j.itl J3's.3 .ric )l e.6, irL,j*"yl

<*i- iS-+

"...:. o;tiX ;_!o-irLl f.Ji: .,lc iJJ--n" 1'6..r.-4- ,f'tJ .i.{l-"c XJ f€.$+:.r. r*:.:,ll u.:r:r Js,-':,j'tJ.t4:11 e+:Ils 4Jl Lr-il| urXl 6.:Gr lllyl ;a

.-. r:i, i;Lr^.jlsJ,r:- qrr,.rll i.^<-.ll Jl lrGiil lil f.r-JJ r.-l twl ,"

.{:.1! 6JjJl L^411 r3.r.' 6d ,,Jl .,i L-<Jl J'ir ,41 6Jj? iJ. e+.;} 4iJtJ)

ri..,Jll.l ;; "L<3t r*--ll Jt"r,Jt*l ,ta:l.ri,,-i 4l il3Jl c,li-)L-Jl .r3,-,r

.€l-,-).,- iJl:- Ji A-al.l 1c ,s.rl

i3rr 6l tl"SiYr l+li ii}JJ ,.1. ; alK a<Jl -,1 i...1 rJ: nl j!-11 - t

i-SJl ;i (JL AllJl i-;LJlr iilLJl rl ,....1 ,r"14 )l-!.i- a<Jl ,:rS- a .6J.-i

tr-Jl 3 G.r3 iJ;'Jl ;..^^ u Ll',;ill eLir c,,,c. J:-"1

;! alLY!.jS:;1 ):-,Jt -J.i+ c,j.-i ,ri" Lr!;jlt L"<J -lJ+? _ o

6$ &JS: ;i iL_*:r lg K^ '.', Ll ,,u.j;i i;s.r o;e;G -*-Jl l{Jl. ;|rjll .r*Jl

. i-nill cill !"j*y 1$6; A,-;|JJ ixL- u-Xl

;l qlr-i J"<, ssJ r=-.!l ',J-!i ._*i ,J. +Jl tlt-! ,1" -..u:: - 1

L+:* .ri 'lf U ,r;-:lt .rLS 3.ll .Ji-Jf a(Jl ;l: rr ,.. l,; ,,,-!ll lJi e+.-i

e+.,-:3 i(JI Jl 4:li.,.,ll .i:'"1 Jl1rl .j" r,151 aiil :. ^ ri Jl ...atl rl L*rlL

I. . t ii- r+&JJ i. Yt &-+ \YY T

,,ti,,..-i #Jl .,l" -,-. r .lpJ,!:ll ,Jc fr.-;Jl ,;r:cl lili ,/J.!ill -1,.i L- t*--'-

a<-ll ;LS )b iji- $1S q;- t++j,sUl 'l+b ls *- ^u c,L;l;:-cYl .sr

ill-iil f<J! ,rt,: 6ill c;J.iJ+ll gliJt ,J*1l .r" .ej r,l ;l-'i4yl o.rn ;? 1.r,.G

.c.,1;lJirYl oJd L!*tl Li.Jl JJI c,i^;i ri Jdill *-.-r-i nS dL

eJE ,iL:: g". ,l*Jl J! t+ "rs-ell ; ^ lrl ;l iil-rr?l ,,/ i+Ell 6t< i! - v

-r:;;1 6.,-.,-Y JLIJI i.-,(L j t ^ (..,. : rlri-3 JlJ.llL L.-aG,'.",Lll ;),ls I

cE'Utt b+'rs o3.rl crJl ,JtJl ,'tJ .iLll N+i i,. ..:1i 1..0+ l.5rG.r1Jl ;',, f,oll

d,!,', $'tll ;S-Jl,',lS e,;)rtul +, lLi Ji,l.--:.ll',Jn: &rS+ - C t'"K: C tt'

'>t; cp,l-+Jl ..,-.it('l! ilLlq ,r":sl3 .iJJ,.e Lla! gcu.Jl gGa;c.-'i:t1 ,3

.JJ'.-3J| aJLc .ri +.,)1J., ;,c

AiS-all

-,J'iIl rl .i.:...11 ,:..11 o)8(,J1 }J.ill 1L.--3;1591 g&g)u)l ":.

.iJ3l.rll .lr,.3 i-i1'/13

. qK;Jl +cl .;sl .i:i-l ;stll ;l .',:-

J,--:: - BlJJVl Jit-r d.i iu+Il fJl J. dl--l-,.Jle - 9t33Jl ;! c,--- 3

Ar-J. ... . irJ....... 6r.c'Jl LGi.r-Hl-e C.lJl L-"!J;,''-q-tlt At sj

....... iLJ..... ,1..,il1 .lir+ #l +X'l *r;;t-LIt iL.3 !]!ttll +;rtill

y'3Xl ,',-, u.Jl tf;r;,. ilLr.ll L"ui l'r -' "'lllL-yl cri 'i':tl i-J;" r'rl '^ll

c+-n..ri a.+ i-.;r r[el A"(-"J ,d;J'rl ef"- ro o:lt:! Jl J!]XL qJl JLilL

..... ... a^-i[i-yL f<-Jl lJ!;,-ctul -iri:-! .ol]lLlL;*Ss o;r-lil g.r3'r3 i..;a5

;^t.-.,--',-!t+ L"S--Ll .-..:i \ -../\/\\ 6,-u5.3 6-;alill ...... .... i:*J ......

Jr+ p.+ u'l-/l teli e+l 6Ji. q$l ;.-.i33,,;nJl &-A fSJl l.r'a,r'a ectUl

,Je J"Lll .-;+ ,fSJl ,,-+ pJGrtl js -JUl! 6r.. d,'t."ll ,:..'.trL i'rlll

tetr lljjJl -..,r:ll te...i- ,l o-lL! i*.L c,.r.r--i !JJ*L i-iJc j;-d..-tl or.!

\TYO Y..l tus ..FAaJdr rt :,,,'l.r

C djl 5t.i,l ar; iu'rlJl a-.*JL;,r],.Jl Jr+ p-: 1.crll ,+- r! ,',:^,r

.'..4 qJ" rj qJ rF4 Cs t++ a_,t+ d; U+,-iJl ,r.! c,lJL aJ u.3;

o,.:;al.ll ,ji Gl$?ti:.itill ,;15 U i.-ii L.[i ,{L. .,.i iJ! lii.l! er^j

Cs't*J* fa;r" U*,;.lt i* d.r ,,r-;Ell ..:=.;r 1Ll c,lJt d +=3; I cJlll

o.G,''-".'llL Jl'l! .,1:. ,i .1" J,tll l.ra uctUl fGl L< ,s-+ {:L Jl d i<=:

4l i^Jt j-tll Jr+ p".2"i f ;r .:JUt

a-'K*i!ll 4rl irl ;qi"-l ili: t- l.r Qs,.'tll cr! ."^j^,,

d J\F,.--illr iU.ll +1-i,.r:.rl.-tl #l rL u,cttll 6L.,lt f ,! ": ^.r

,:*.tll ; Lsr;It i-tll t-[_* 1s.r. -ili!:-Yl A.<=- fLi e[ ..^'r .r,i etli t n -dt

l{. iJ L+1 fi-Jrll Jl;,'c + - p r.r-jJl .,lc qS,;+.iJl -,*-LJl: elJl Lar;

.:.< ^ L-<.-ll .:.;Ke ,{j',i'u Jlj.ll r,;irl cl iJi?l 8.11')! ri (JL.J ..rt$l .r.,

1l;\ Ln,.: ".l'l.ll Dl.c'! e,JE ,!+l i{.-n j+ul i:Xll . L',ll .-lJnL .l *-:,ll

,rlill ii.l. ^i j$i] ,l-r+ a;x tl-i.i ,Jl-i,ll ilJ. j L ( jr .^r Jl ':u H--J!

CU r.,, - &LJl J,Fl -i)i (Jlc JG,ll aU;r" !i, ag l3.r.,Jl lJJ-J.it lrE $r

.Ll .r.[Ul .'!...^::, ,ic<Jl Li.r-r.= ll i",-ll ,-r -,!i --i 1.i..',J.-<] l-.r-!lJ-J,!rvJ-tv

J --ilLJl <rG.r +-r-i.',^- Lll ^(Jl .r,* Ji ', -il| I$ ,',)tL- --iU!:.-Yl a-S..-.

qll ,^4 4ji L"nq 'liijs- ,"1 ',:ll J,',-,il o+l! ,-..{:il (J]ll ;i i:t!L i;'b ,dlr' J}

.r-!:.,.ar':-.* a-.-,r, L -oas <J Lf ,...i o**1 ,+r--s

6Jl r-'.3;L.3 6r'cJl -*Lc,x-a;;i ,.:ll'i.41=- d,Fl ll^;! e+-s

LFll ,.;U q!., l}* ar" ri L{+ i:;l3ll3 iJ.rl (-l. lJ+ L ",oJ-".-il l{ ::,

J+:i .,Jl 6rtcJl ; dl Yl ,'r+ t.61i

';$* ri ol3J ld'.. ,rli+;i 5'-.,. -Y .;.ll

;1 ef-.": Xi - l-{. fu)l ;c LU! u;lrll .-irU- ,.ir ai-. a.ri r-i L,.i l4lJj

r-,. ^r JIJ ,r:+ irr-:+ ijL,r-Jl ol ,1,& - *--+ t.(+i 6i;Jl .lrY {Ut .!.tr

.1.11- .JJ+ #; ;i ,l . ^ r ;Yl .!'e L"<--^ll, ol .,lc c,,l jiYl ;.r.,G .r. \f o irUl

,i+Jl L_rr,.il I -".,iJ L;l J:, (]) : I ( "<- jqrt-. .,-! JS$ si :,i:.r <i)li 3l .r*13

r..l r.is Ji!.+J g, It 4,,,r. \rY1

fJ*ll GA u'. ril \Yl iJUl c,r--.J ... l-ailj.il ,r" ol nijg .,ll iLt Jl -x*l.t:ll-t

-L- l- * iJEll le:'in d -..^'u .L"S-.ll o",-e lb .,*+!l ..,rl.rl ,sL jt1:Xl

-,-. .J q.iLJfl ,lr+-=Jl .r--l 3l ,r+.dl .,^t^ll i,..i Jl ,l-.a!l -..-'<r,.-Jill 4tS ljl3r

dl .q-e 6!l .H-,-=Jl L,--ti q*,i LL"ll El.r! tnrtLi! ,rF L;yl.rXl iaJl ,rlc

. . '.t ill . \ i. i.rlll -<^ 4-!.s. ..i,"...=,.,''^...'Jl l.i-r. i..^(Jl i y.l o L,o-"ULlrJ

qll La.rti-! .,* 1!i i,,.; Jti i.-{ll ,l.rl "p _*+Jl ,r-ar:,rl a-.<.-Jl ;1,r ,r.lc

#-':;l f$;S l.e. rKrl {^ctl & il ib - UJ+.. rrr*-l ,c+l ,r. !t.,b,q

,n<5-.,.riJl ol,l_.;,.JL JIi.l J*+ c,l .;#.ills l*"fl ,,s !,+.i .,:Jl ,:,li,r-;. ^tL 4-..18

o. q!3Lr,tl .lr+iJl .liil,-t Ls*--Y,r cl .rLl. !l .r;L!J q=L,nJl LSJrI c,i";:J

J--i,: Jl -..rJ ,l . ' :ll alGr;i i! - \ !. 6,:Lll 6l - s,,.,,l ;.rUl i .51;Jl #Jl

,rlc LlelQl i-6.-ll .-illi,l LLiJI 6L6;c,r:i.r-Y3 14+ &-F,:+ Lr,.- ,t-*:.lt

6rteJt .,lc -,,-n-Yr,-i.,L- Jl USJ,-;J+ Ljl .-ib,-i)l li-o;X Q elll 'jJl

g. 6-*1 ,_11 Ji+!l .r":l cl e,l;. )l ..rita ,-r" \ !A ;.rU qi. .r nl e ., i *r+ ,rJt

.dli .,.i dJ ,Jil J3 f<Jl ;tS l;! )! f<Jl';rl gL"- ra 6;a g'" ri a+,-ll fa.r^-

i$l'.^lt ,aecrJl J.J a.r.s-tl rLXl , j ,..11 ,9;5. a:s-, c,L-il Jl jlL! 6t< rilJ-tl-

js p., -u;Jl ar" 4jG-l ,L l*Al Jri dt" - L;Y "r+-;,S d rl ,ts

Lj^ cjGr:,-L .,;*"ti;i i-S-Jl;l r'. ,:,Gl \ oY i.rUl qlc c,,^i I ^i 'l:,'i<l u-ill

",.1.C "^.ld .r- Lrl.r L3 ,-l-Jt 6i+j .tJ"-ll =S ,rL 't+ sl l( . ..;'. "Li.J5

l 1.e.1 . ' -6rt c,l d . .1.'i ElJl +L+ \1oy a-iJ t] irJ,itiJb .c,L,-ll_/|3 c,l-:. !lv r.l I

ur*L-ll f-o "t . ';ll ;lra!1 ;l a.o Ul . r-"!l {JJJI ;rpti r.. \r\ 6.rUl q.L c,.-:

,lr+:ll ;1 "! - J+ elli ,-[.] <, ".+r;113 .u.r,;Jl3 ;:.< tlJ /l ,[."tJ ,LrJlJ--liLl .r..:.. .r.c Jl r. AiL:.-Yl *.-,Y ,,1 . '-"ll .',l.s.l .'- ,',^.^= Jt .',:L^ir -",i-:r

"lr. L - v \t

i-rll-,a!." f+-r-.e- J'lr ,il1^-Yr tes e--i d L-;rnlt "-u:l ;!-l ,ijL,:-il .i4J4Jl LJnl iJ.#l 6iGl, fQl ,r^ 4-""-ii-' a<-+ L.i.s .,;LilJ E u-.i.Il f"rJ; .,J6-

ld.i':l lil fr-Jl Ut *-,tdl -,<.*-'.r-,_,+Jl c.a.i-i, .r.r r - r ,ir ,k,1+ g1+!lr

;13.i-^6-Il ('+,-* e-^,n- J.4iJl4.-. :J iJ lal;J-Jt<J i- d,.r: sJl i.<-ll Ji

I ' . \ aj4 JJ!aJ !J, lt a.Jrlr

(,-i 4l ilFl ,:,L,.r)l-Jl ,t.r=s .a+l! E$-ll i-+l $.11 q+.r:ll ,r-o aj=fl

,{:lj-y-,- Jl r rir"61l r+ 6.11 3l ,..,.ri:,!l _4i;t-<3t,SJl Jb-c Jt .i.l.&:lJl

.sFi li.rr 6i d"Si )J l+-,li 4jir.J,- s.i aLL< +Jl .,rr...i Jj Ji J',-1lr

.-.,.-r:...1 i.SJl ;l (Jlc illJl {-.;l!b aiLJl c,L-l ,;c )t i,i. #Jl JrqF

c,iil ,r; r-J;Jfl i.G1 ',r- {il Xl tr,,-!l gG.:3 ihXl c,.^-1J gl..;ll fG3

;l .s,r., or.-r: r:+;Jl l{Jl. (Jii (Jjll cj,-'rl (,l! ilt=}q.FSS;1 l+:.tl >j+

cltiJ i:,.ri.s i-,-iKJ i.s;l$ ijjL* o**'rl oia,_r.lS qji iLJ*ir l{ ^<- ui LaJ+

J.S,rJ.l ;'+,Jl l.,J,!: u*i + fJl ilL'!,+ J. J+ +:!j JtjJtr i.+idl

,i itt u .-::tt ;ts.g ."f,--l a<-Ll ,tp; L; ..*ilr t.ra 61t-1ai tt+-i

15Jl Jl iili *Jt ri-l jl,3'rl .r" r+t:Jl ;;1tr " 3l Jl ...itl rl -,r',-iJL i,.J-.

#l "1" ?-. r JJJ,i:ll ,-$ rs-^.lt u;ricl lili.J.lJi:ll .-1,-i t"a'l!i,- e+,-+

;t-< Y!;;c- .:itS "i- t+:" cs't-rll "1,r.,13 ls . ^.,^ ^is oL;l,;sYl o.ra Jy-;fJl ?-.ri ljJl .s}.r+ll LLIJI eli+;r .:.,: .:L;l-;-cYl oj.o;1 't_r..-t 1('.tl

ojqJ t ; ...t1 ,Jj.;ll .1Jl .-.'. - . r'r !3 .,*+3Jl JJJ-i,i u*l .,S fL- dt ; :t

.l-*Jl J! l.6.1 .r,x.Ll i^afl ;1 relrll .,-l +ul ;lS3 ,JJj alS U - c,!;lJieYl

J!-Llt i$l .,-i 1,.( jJ.^rJlri-rrlrilL L^.0,r-.' ;"",11.1 jrl.c! 6t-rE.,l,*.rrr

siJl Jt Jl

"'t3

,i.SJl il-+r., r,. Ji4 Lr+ I.rL3.r"ll a'tr,aJl ,r..,':;1 g-.^,J

;tS3 ,;){J.Jl <.,11-.1 ,r3 .l-.r--tl -',-;o;:S+l +, l,"lE: pJ q- cs'bll l3,r'g o3.l1

ilGlli,r-i<b ."Jl <131

":l! ,Li.tl ;rctUl gL!.r cF c,ill S gl;rl"Ll #,ll

.<- A$ -,.a. . J,$ ,x.i L- rJ,.-ill 6Jl-c $ 4.,)tL Jc )[;i d!.i ,lJrll ,J.ir Jl