نقض حكم قضى بعدم جواز الاستئناف على حكم عدل قرار تقدير تعويض المطعون ضده عن نزع ملكية أرض مملوكة له

\YAt

t r t \ J...., J+.ogljJ 0F6 \ y a,_r[r

;.rt ..Jl i,-+cr L"Gll u+J *':U s,il_Jl rt ^ ^ /)t .r.1 ...1I +Jl i_l-::,.

il-Il . *,!- r -1, J.:r !^ .;_,,J1 +. l-Jl r,c ,c.JrJl 6JS.-L/a.,rl .i. :. ..1I

.",t-ra;;lJl .lc. s

(Yrl)

ajl.^a(l oV a.rld Tt. dJ i*hJl

;,-irl'.'....1 .oar. '. ll .o:,r.rtl t3,.r nE.o+J*jllrcrer-Jrr'j.a-sft g,;, (f .t)

.(FsJl d irLJh rells .u-rk ;1at'tiilt .!=tla: (rii rt.r rl ' &lJlJl r.r.3pr fs

sr J.+ilI AL+l ,]lJli qi iJ,JJl .Ji+ i-.:lJn'rl i-.s.Jl L,-l - - i rl (\)

f hia iJunf l crL;g*:Jlj l{i5L i-e$Xl ol-;ti,Jl i-:L- ,.1L:; ,r-i B;.rl ll ,:L;;Lll

AbJl Jl)j ii-iL,- u.i rEtJl (J]., L.<rtl L-)3 rl . -': :; .ol.r3- . \ 101. iiJ oW J \ t

et+lL .,i Ljt ;,i ..L:j-yl .qil'.:: . ..)u la-^<= qltl p.lc .r6s. J,6 .:, iGll lir tl,L?

r, e i_.rLll JIJ'iJI .,i Jl--ill u3.r 6urcJl ,-[,1.i 1.q sl iiJll + I o -.rL ,-:l-+ ;J iq"1

..:Ui iL.l(rl. A;$r-;ils crlltL (,i ii.slll ;1t ll3 r:.:,:ti!l .rl-rtl j l*-Ll

,.,.d1 .rtr "L hrL-iil . \1ot ij-l ow J Jtlj s.i iih:,-yt i"6Jl l:tr (y)

J,rin. '..iij ij-.! L"S.'fl .rlr..lls {ii L+jll_rl,jJl ,rL;_,1lrll oL! ol.)l;;

1.s ..&-r,rjll x$nJ i..,r- J-;J'll tJ-eJl ..,p J-.--iJtJ le <^ .ol.rj-o .;l.l:,! ui.J-ll

a, I i,,rl.ll z'rOtrti .cJ,l . L+jy., .r3.r.- :+! ;.. o,s.r-..a . rll,i iL .i+l+ll , i. .J r.r . ..i(l

.rr, r-r-i;J o, :.r,g-Lll ,.lFl Jle f.irr a+Jl ,.,p;1.;i ,3a-,o .rl.rj- ..ilr'.'r ...)L

nF 6dl iJl ,-alr.,.r ')ts;;lr:^cxl !L.-,i..r duJ! i+li-,'yl i. lt ,r .:ir Jr -Jll

1-l jJ',]rll rs-Jl ,l-;3.Lfu,r-ill >JE".r iiJl tlJnl 6J..Jl Jr+ rr+;!.11 "etul.iLi .-iL::-Yl jlr+ tJ+

.,-X iJ+ - 1<^ tl oi.l ,Li! 11 ,..t: L ul"s - cF:ii i:6lJn'yl i.Ssfl 6l - \

rl i-L,Jl i+iiJJ crLl i .ll i.SL L, a'L+ \to t ilJ oW tlJ JitiJl ;" \ !. i.rLtl

Y,.l air J+a..P r. ry ilrt r

j ilLJl el ;_rlrll ,/ J-itt ,t!,rl.rl;; kJ! f* rlt ;"..!lt ,Li,.q....-:ll

,J4;JJE4L Jil l-d,-)J.i .tF" ;JJill cLjJJ4:lb r{:<r- A"$rfl olrr:.lJ| at* .-

t-{-"S-J ,d iiilL.-tL rl artill .:lli tts--', Lol*" r.,- .r.i i:s.lJl ,lr!;lS ljl t-Ji JLXI

(J.i i-.il$,Jl ixJt Lr;tt iJL -ilij.-yL 1i.i ,.4l"ll J,u J$ tJkr a'rq J.r-jll tjn (,.i

,l 6.r,sr,".rJl .hip,.3l c,l iJt*ll ,,s J-=il| r+J,+ t6^rt.rj,"r C i+r+ c,tru

c,l..!L ; iiJll i'" rJl . ^llr ;riul .rLJl ; tgLl 1}i i.-!fl JlJill ; r{j ^K $i;

6Il Jtlnll ,r3.rs J,:i jo_p.r-,-al l(<- J+lijL{Jl . :.., 6t-i . ts",t. i-1lJL $K

;qir -iliij*rL {.+j .'-tll \Li JrS-. f: !,.r ,i:ilJn-yl i^l-ll _uSJ,l rljLi {--r

.,:tr.ll../l ;;G; LLrJl "rc.l3nl

\10t il-J ow iciLill (Jjl{Jll Jl .}.r.1 arl }ttl)L€iJl ii-Jl cnLS il -y

ll-:r<t. i.gjill slrl :.Jl i-11 ... ^;i.-j ,r-n El.rt ll c,r . r-,L,ll .,; Jl,a-ilt i,.a-i.sll

.rr- *ri;J oui.r:rrlll (J;lj.l {}r,r fJ+ LaJlJ,i c,J, 1 -C (l_{j4 EJrifl c,t . :#-'itb

J5e.r;b3l li!,Ul.L c,^<^ ull \.:t.!:.'yt it-tl tt l {+ r+11 6,1 jb,Jt4.I

,i-i!Jl 1l,riY ('r,cJl J5;1.u1.r.,151 ;ctl.Jl ; (Jdl iJl FiJ*J ')S*i (J,:ljlXl

,rJl .rj.r-Jl s-ir - i,jli:,Xl ; -<* ll L-!'9 dt< ib . i,Stl L.1, ,"F ,r..*r-Xl ilr..,,t,r'Lr

,Jc iJJ',5i. - i"sJl o.r.r,r.::{6rs L,}r- llo!, iiJ ow,j-) onLiJl t+*-r

jrin d-i:i i.+.:'J-r.l+:ll _rt.iiJ.l .rr rlll .:lrl.r-!./ kJ! fS,rll ,.!..tll rln

. i. u 43.J_Y !r;,$,ijl J]rifu i.c- rGJJ.l eJ'rJl d,laiJL tl.<- ;Li:lJi,l ,J:,J-:ll

{4i J,Ltl )LLi - L,-J-.-:JI li! ; - s--.nJ ..,. ta:.-Y3 .r3.r.- -4i s.a arJJ,J i..it+Jl

d.l-i ,.-iljji,-tl jL,s tsr srJs JAilt tJ.6 qi arj,lJ #.Jt -iJli Jb .ju:i_yL

.du'iLill LaJih d'dJl arl"c r!,.,-c1

ajSs.ll

,2L;il1 ,1 .;.':...(1 ,r ..tl o)b 6ill :pJ.i:ll 1t"-,3;l-r.:r'Jl .rJ.6}ttyl .s

. iJ3l.dl .r*.,.3 i-il3ll3

.LK*:J! cil .':r'l ;j.*l idlll Jt ...:-

-;,,lll ;l,3i >L: !j a,:.,tll +Jl D- A*1" + - iLiJI ;! e,:.=.r

l..l fu4 +4.ar !,. lIt,.la

t-,r I "J,r-,.r- \14' iiJ vAY g;6ul-.rJl 1L!l o.r--,--;u"tll ;l; 'J'--'-.j]

c,SI" 1* .rll *&.-? + l:! tdt* ui Jtn3 .6:t a' . fY, .,Je 4i!h:.,.Yl

;t<...1 \11 pl-; eu.ul .,i iLl.l:Il \Y + Llill ;"-; b.-r- lJi.Y' t Lu

l$ + .;FU,t-{n+J-i,E i-*.-i. t.JAl Fl ;i..,r!-r,trJ "l Jr,,Jt.-:r

t,l!l c.,,;,r,-G 6i[-,,.,-o.- vAlA1 pJ o;lriYL i"-Ell irJll fl-i ]JnJl

#Jl ol3,c.r plii-i ,.rt41l ,r., <.-i-/ ";Li"!l &+ fr,r \1A'/\/\ o .,i Urly

Cf+ f-&,t+,e.ct!lt 1l}[ e- {ii+ iil.? y.-/l ;:tl ..r- }';is ' LAJIJ-! ' LXli

ilJl c,,.r.t . t , r -.,<l ^ r_JJill .F;?l ,-J- LLill dL.ll iln .liG- **+ *]*:)L:

;l ,-ur,.3 .riii.,-. 'Lin! {.61 . ::l Jr+s p.l.,t .,rlll ;rctul y'r3 .6J"eJl i l-'+:

,iJl ,;r...r..ib:.xl &.i.. .r ilJll ,.,1-rr'H!;."sJl d:-:i ,o,*!; *Jl p;

;- elJj l.rs L c,;i# isrl &-1,, ip i,:.,-r,-, t41.+.+L:,r -i:1 i.,.Ji llr -*n]t

.-iUiji.-l Jot iiJ \Yl f.3J.-il;:j-)t .(JI li.t i$isttll -ili-:-l .c,LJUl

i.-.:cttll .',,! ..-!l$-"!l .1l.* e.r.r a-(Jl c,.<.- \141/\Y/A g,-r|ns .tx-i

ib J-tll .;3r cs'r-,Jl le :i o+1 6ii- q$l c-,r33 .".-!:Jl ;$,J.ty f<Jl lb .,i

.-. !: tl I ( t is 6JE-il t-J+ ,:.rs-r E ,;r-..i.o f.i, ., i."(Jl o.u .,Jr irrlll , ;i

tq'b Clill

qi;"crl"Il 15Jl .1";,-&tul q ,r,+ .r-13:,i- .,L 6li ;',lll ;l ':-,r

i,'" J*",rl" -!l'.'.r...X1 -.:ls+ l.!r* s-d "il ,:Lli G+J"l .,i it:JlJ &Jjbll i-iJl-i-.

;.rca \1o1. A.iJ ovv 1.oJ &illll ;,. \ t. E.rUL'fr-"-;t.r,'Xt #l "+!te Uratl

si f; r:L;|./l ..,iLl .r" YY\ i.r[l .r";$t'l-i-tJ nil",'rtlt c,)l- 6.s! ]ljn

.rJ. oL;;t ll ,,i J.,-ill iiJ c,lrlJ-3 ,,14,',-.,U1 J.t.:; {:,.:|s.,'y I a."SJl L,YJ

3l lr'::a1r- 6.l. j J-ll ,Jc _.,--:!i LLJI A,-u^ll iSUl e.;,., "c "r.;*:Jl ;$;

l.r.a .,.i t e <^,.S-:,c,qlt n + J,-i L+ .:llir &11 ;,|'iJl 1lS-=X l t': t't g-

Al Ji-+ d t^iJ -.1. ir .;thlt l.r-a ar r.s.. F ;!i .i.,lll J',13 J+ ii:Ld lt*iJl

ilr,re^<^ JJ-! i:,JlCl ..iL,.3;!i tr;r.ttl iaf,r" Js,]tt lill- ar-Il d.-..:r.

a.r.'. lr rl ;3 1l.r,ol .r-- a,c irrLlJ -r;;!+ll i-llt- i;Jll .;i ;l1Xl o'. ;'ilJl ;tsl.

; L-2l-i^U.;r:::;i u,.r,r .rL-Jl J-:4-iJ')dS^:r o'r; &J',tIl gr.l-i-cl ,-L+3

,-Lj. r JlJ.lll lia..r;li;1 + - rF-1.4 i! ;lJn)l f<Jl 9!-l ,";or'-ll ,',.r-i:

l..l Lis J+.r.:U i. \t L.rh

J4. d ir-lll ..rl C. ,.r-..r.-'.Jl _;,,rx .ru.ij ,i..,!- JJJ, LJ""JI _ 'ltS; i;rt_,ft

.qll ..,Lill ;3:l-!Jl Lr,r.s.jll c.-X3;,.5F r; al(* cp ,;'r_^:nl l.r,a j l(.l ^K

,c,l-.-il_.2l1 &;ti lJ.i i-.trll .t..,leiJl ;-13 + J,lll lU Jfrl! ,.-_;l f ,-r.,r

.{,;3j ,,..r.r..,J t-i t.r- JnJl ljj 4iijtr -j (l! ij,tll #Jl i".1-r

cr,r.= L.rL,, -, 'a:ii;::tri-,-Jl iX--ll el clJj ,.rs- sJl l$;l :,*-.r

;i-L \10 t. ii-J oW llJ ailnI 6. \ r. ;;ul "dl ti_rr - i-<Jt a.i.6 et . :; {./ L'g3J! fJi,rXl ayLll J,ii-,.it-".-ill Jl i-[Jl a+ij,.ll c,lJt :,ll +X. t]ir .j,-.Il gbl -. - ll 4..-l . ,l'1.:r ,r-i il.rl . -ll ot . :.rl,ll ; Jt-_ill ,L+l ol..,|-1.!

Jlj6tS lj! t"! JiJl (Jlc;_,J',-i. Ji! t{n-yri.td" i;$ll c.,L;.3Jr:Jl3 tl.:r<r^

e. .|.ll lii "t' lo <^,r .41 i-ilL=lL ri a,Jilill ,il; plS--X i_ul3- r.r.,- rn a_islll.rlilL q/ i.jl'!n'yl i.SJl #nr dt -iLj:i*"YL d-,i;,,!ll "l.U Ji. 't+t+ ajq

cli &JJ 6u,c'Jl JrS p,r ll c,t . 'rL,ll ,r"i J,-ill ii,.J ulc t( ^rL J-t d S+ ,..

(Ji Ai-Jl ;p')rlJl3 ,r:.iLiJl .rt.+(l j L{-t"l gi a,_"r.Lll _,I_rlJl

"p

te r "ts Jr :

{JsJi,c,rJ o_plJ l{ ^<- JJ-Y i:.iLdl . .,..r,1!.i.l.61lc L=3.}- c;lS oLJt

a,;;e!.lJ \U a-9(1 f .r".r .iJlJgl a.S-Jt JrSJfl urut 4*J 6Jt JttlliiJll cnKr ,.rIi ;L-s Ll ,c,1, al_rll drjG ; i-Lnl .s[r-iJl 613 -i1..,..r . ..yL

;!..11-=.fl J,i {.-iJ o.r..o..ro,-Lll u.olJic'l d},i lJ,i LaJl}.:'1a-,-l .r! i..-jill

*!.-i.. .J JIJ-iJI li^ ,lilli..<- ,rll i+jhn'yl i_.(Jl fL*l {*lc J,ij-'fl Jr!

,Li-:iy 6r,EJl Jr"l p+;tiJl ,ctUl .,.6+l eiJl L;i,,.r it_<;, r;tr:-:,t

;r - 1gl$,Jl i.(ail L-Xr c,-jls ib .i,<lll L, aF un-r,:ll Cl+" jJi:..r .in-lt

oi.a,L-oj ! cr>+ L J-lcJ - \tot iiJ oW f"r.rrUtt te ^ -.u.;Jl .r3.dl

,Wl :Lill ar a tll c,tJLJ ./ Wl pa,r_,I &r,tlt J.tr ,J" E-U',-i- _ i.sJl

t3,-lJl ,rj rl,--i'lL l{ <^ "!-i il.*! .F*}Jl ,,. :',,. .,-:.=; iila .-. ...ll.r[.4.1X3 r3.r-- :c.r"i o-,9d qjt-dl -ir-J {il-X u4#q11 } {ir]J i,,cJ;J,ljb .-itiir-YL !i .J.t! )-,G : c,-.1*--Jl lL! .,"i - .-,;-r .. rl* L.r-, rslc

o-,ls, .ri;r.4 dJ.i ,-itni*,Yl rlr= + ,r,:ir rCrll l.ia !i &pLU f<Jl ._ilti

.dLXl L;il1 6- r-fr.ri (JJc 4,:!i.:.iJ: t i dritXl ,3*t;; tr^r 11